Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts

25 June 2011

Syria, Libya, Bahrain... and Elena Bonner. A connection?

Soviet dissident, Yelena Bonner

I haven't been writing that much lately, as life does get in the way, but I still follow to a degree with what is happening around the world and, most significantly, how it is being packaged. What recently grabbed my attention was the recent death of prominent Soviet dissident Elena Bonner, wife of Andrei Sakharov. What amazed me was that she was still around! Ever since the fall of the USSR, in my mind she had totally disappeared from the radar, if you were to go by the amount of coverage she had been receiving (i.e. next to nothing). I wouldn't be surprised if many of the younger journalists out there would have had no idea who she was. Her comparatively low profile of late in the Western media would lead to believe that Bonner was quite pleased with the way Russia and the successor republics have turned out and her job in Soviet times had been completed by 1992. However, what surprised me about this report of Bonner's death is that she had continued her struggle for human rights. Initially under Yeltsin's rule in the 1990s (which according to accepted, but essentially flawed, Western lore was a time of 'true freedom'), Bonner was supportive of and played an active role in the new 'democratic' clique; however that changed when Bonner split with Yeltsin over the launch of the military campaign in Chechnya in December 1994. From then on, and more so after Putin's ascendancy to power in 2000, Bonner yet again became an opponent of the new, authoritarian Russian government. She also was quite vocal in her opposition to elements of various proposed Israel-Palestine peace accords, siding her very much on the Israeli hawkish right-wing - something of an inconsistency in principles when human rights for all is concerned. Bonner's continued dissidence is surprising in that prior to 1992, under Soviet times, Bonner had very high Western media exposure, to an extent that went far beyond her the level of her influence or profile in the USSR (many ordinary Russians still have no idea who she is!). Given that Bonner continued with her struggle in much the same intensity over the past two decades, despite the fall of the Communist Party, why did the Western media turn her back on her?

OK, I can answer that on - Bonner was no longer useful for Western interests. As I have previously commented about how different emphasis is placed by the media around the world in highlighting a cause or 'dissidents' out of self-interest above principle, Bonner and her fellow Soviet dissidents helped in achieving what the West wanted - to provide a 'moral' basis for the overthrow of Communist Party rule and to pave the way for the installation of a new capitalist system in Russia (note, not necessarily a 'democratic' system). By doing so, big business in the West stood to make loads of money from Russia. Bonner post-1992 had turned from someone who could help to make this change happen to someone who just made a lot of hot air. So not only was Bonner no longer needed by the West, she was an anachronism, hence the lack of Western exposure about her continued work.

Margaret Thatcher, Andrei Sakharov and Yelena Bonner. Who's serving who?

So how does Elena Bonner connect with Libya, Syria and Bahrain? Well, again, it involves coverage priority and an agenda grounded by Western big business interests with right-wing ideology. All three countries have experienced uprisings of various degrees, and all three have responded violently to them. However, the Western response to these 'revolutions' have not been consistent with principle. Libya is experiencing a Western intervention on the side of a murky group of rebels in what has now become a civil war. Syria faces constant demonstrations by the majority Sunni Muslims in regional centres, with constant reports of violent crackdowns. Bahrain, after mass protests in its capital, called Saudi Arabia in to quash the 'Shia' uprising and its authorities, through police intimidation and show trials, ever since have created an atmosphere of terror and fear so as to maintain the political status quo. However, what differentiates these crises is how the Western media is reporting about them.

When Nato decided to lob missiles into Libya, the first casualty was the truth. Since then, we in the West have been forced fed a steady stream of Nato propaganda. Having learnt from extensive experience in military campaigns in Yugoslavia in 1999 and Afghanistan since 2001, Nato has successfully convinced the West's media to toe the line that the mission there is 'humanitarian' and 'moral'; Nato is killing the 'killer' before it kills, so to speak. News about the Nato bombing of Libya comes solely from Nato sources i.e. Western governments. There is never any news of civilian casualties, let alone images - out of mind, out of sight, so to speak. Any Libyan news of the civilian deaths is quickly made out to be crude propaganda - well, takes one to know one. And the 'rebels'? A certain ambiguity is maintained as to their agenda, plans, structure and composure. This helps in keeping a fragile hope that they may conform to the self-formed, idealised and romantic image Western media consumers would like to have for them. What really seems to be the case with Western policy in Libya, is that Western big business can see huge amounts of money to made. Coverage of this bombing only serves to provide popular consent and a moral high horse for the Western public. The money in Libya comes not just from large oil reserves, but also because of Libya's centralised and socialised economy. Libyan public services and utilities are still largely in government hands, so a new Western-client state in Libya would then be forced to sell off its rather valuable assets such as telecommunications, water supplies and transport. This sell-off would mean bargain investments and, considering how cashed up Libya has appeared to be, potential huge profits for big business. The connection with Bonner here is that the 'rebels', who may be quite sincere with their aims for a fairer Libya, are just being used by the West now as they are useful in creating change to a capitalist system and, subsequently, massive profits for Western big business. Plus, to some on the extremes of ideology, Libya's war can be seen as a crude but visual battle of the Right triumphing over the Left.

Nato being 'humanitarian' by destroying Libya to save it

Extensive and prominent media coverage is given to Syria's opposition protests. Images are shown of civilian casualties, numbers of deaths heavily emphasised and a simplistic, good vs evil scenario is being painted with the majority Sunni Muslims portrayed as pro-West, pro-democracy and 'good', while Bashar Assad and the 'ruling elite' from the 'Alawite sect' ('sect' has negative connotations - it is deliberate that this is how the West describes the Alewis) are evil. There have been no calls (as yet) for foreign intervention in Syria on humanitarian grounds like Libya, but Western media coverage too has sacrificed principle for interests. The West too would like to see Syria's left-wing government fall for much the same reasons as with Libya. Syria's economy is still very much in publicly-owned, much to the chagrin of the West's ideology of privatisation at any cost. A new, pro-West government in Damascus, like the West's plans for Libya, will be forced to privatise its assets, only to be purchased at bargain prices by the rich. The only difference with Libya though is that Syria does not have as much oil, so that would explain why there has been no pressing need by the West to engage in a military campaign to 'avert a humanitarian crisis'. As to what exactly this 'humanitarian crisis' is, well, details have never been fully given, nor is it that certain that this hypothetical 'crisis' would have actually happened otherwise.

Anti-Assad protest in Syria

Why get bothered with technicalities?! OK, maybe we should with Syria. The country is much like Iraq - a sectarian mosaic. The majority Sunni Muslims, many of whom are rather pious and see the ruling Alewis, as well as all other religions and other Islamic denominations, as heretics, have in the past displayed solid support for fundamentalist-based movements such as the Muslim Brotherhood. The more religious parts of Syria have mainly been the scene of demonstrations while the largest, and more cosmopolitan, cities such as Aleppo and the capital Damascus has displayed very little support for the opposition. Even though it has been mentioned (although downplayed by the Western media), many Syrians still support Assad as they see secularist Baath rule is the only way of guaranteeing avoiding the sectarian violence that has plagued Iraq since its 'liberation' in 2003. Christians and Shias are particularly worried as they know very well that a Sunni-majority rule, by virtue of imposing its majority in all aspects, will spell the end Syria's harmonious coexistence among the faiths. As mentioned previously, the West has adopted Sunni fundamentalist terminology in describing the ruling Shia Alewi minority as a 'sect'. Based on Western (misguided) perceptions of what constitutes Shias (i.e. like the stereotype of Iranians of today), and as a 'sect' (like doomsday sects), they would appear to be sinister and evil. However, if you were to actually delve into the practices and history of the Alewis (and the related Alevis in Turkey), it would make more sense that based on Western principles of democracy and humanism, the West would support them. The Alewis strongly believe in equality of the sexes (men and women pray side-by-side, Alewi women are not required to wear hijab, and monogamy is strictly enforced), humanism and espouse respect for other denominations and religions - aspects many Sunni clerics believe to be heretic. However, the West supports the Sunnis who, if successful in toppling the secular system under Assad, would most likely impose an austere and considerably intolerant environment in place - a new Iraq. And just like Iraq, Syria would witness a mass exodus of all of its religious minorities (particularly Christians and the last remaining Jews), while the increased Sunni Muslim religious atmosphere would also make the situation for gay Syrians even worse than they are now. Again, like Bonner, the Sunnis are being used (for now) so that the ultimate aim of fulfilling Western interests are served. And then, we are fed with the rather simplistic but inherently false paradigm that Shias are supposedly all anti-West while the Sunnis are all pro-West...

Pro-Assad demonstration in Syria

Then we come to Bahrain. The island state is ruled by the Sunni Al-Khalifa family while the population has a downtrodden Shia majority. Bahrain has an oil-based economy which was one of the first in the Gulf to diversify and become an important banking centre. When the Arab Spring revolution spread to Bahrain, with giant protests in the capital Manama's Pearl Square, the Gulf (especially Saudi Arabia) and the West became tense. Reason being is that if Bahrain's revolution succeeded, then this could precipitate a domino-effect in which the other undemocratic emirates of the region could fall. On a principled basis, this should be what the West wants - human rights and democracy for all. However, in this case this is not in the West's interests. These absolute monarchies, of which Saudi Arabia is the largest, provide the world with much oil and are engaged, and engage in, considerable business worldwide. On an ideological basis, these emirates are extremely right-wing and capitalist. In a move, and for much same rationale that the Soviet Union intervened into Afghanistan in 1979, Saudi Arabia even staged a Western-sanctioned invasion of Bahrain to restore 'order'. According to Gulf propaganda and carried by the Western media, Bahrain had apparently 'invited' Saudi forces in; again, this is what the Soviets claimed Afghanistan did in 1979. Going by Western 'logic', it was wrong for the Soviet Union to go into Afghanistan to contain the spread of Islamic Fundamentalism reaching the bordering, poor, Muslim republics of Soviet Central Asia, but it is fine for Saudi Arabia to enter into Bahrain to stop the spread of democracy and people power. Since the Saudi invasion, many have been arrested, there has been a climate of fear and terror, and even a group of doctors and nurses, serving their Hippocratic oath of treating people regardless, have been handed life sentences for treating protesters shot by Bahraini and invading Saudi forces.

When Saudi forces are 'invited' into Bahrain, it's no party.

So what has the Western media done? While there are occasional reports about the repression occurring in Bahrain, such as the sentencing of the doctors and nurses (this one by the BBC is particularly good), overall coverage has been comparatively light and low profile. This clearly shows that the West sees no use or financial benefit out of democracy in Bahrain, despite maintaining supposed principled and 'humanitarian' stances on Libya and Syria. The fact that the West has given its blessing to Bahrain's repression of democracy-supporters came when a Bahraini prince, who is connected to Bahraini security structures responsible for conducting arrests and torture of democracy activists, and the Bahraini ambassador to the UK were invited to the recent royal wedding of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge. The prince clumsily declined the invite, though the ambassador was there. This came despite much fanfare made by David Cameron's government through the media how the Syrian ambassador was taken off the invite list due to his country's 'repression of democracy activists'.

Naturally, the West, and especially the US with its navy's 5th Fleet based in Bahrain, have no desire for the Gulf state to fall into the hands of the Shia majority. This is not so much the case, as claimed by the corrupt Gulf emirs and their Western benefactors, that this would open the door for Iran to spread its influence, but because after almost 40 years of unbridled capitalism which has seen little of that wealth trickle down to the majority, a new government in Bahrain would move towards a more socialised economy and environment - not what Western big business wants. Plus, the comparative and perceived instability of having democracy in these countries would play havoc on oil prices, driving Western economies into greater economic turmoil. It's always easier to deal with unaccountable dictatorships in these cases, rather than face negotiating with popularly-elected parliaments.

Where are Western principles? These doctors are now facing life imprisonment for doing this.

The opposition in left-wing Libya and Syria are like Elena Bonner pre-1992 - a useful tool for Western big business and government in spreading free-for-all capitalism, while right-wing Bahrain's repressed activists are post-1992 Bonner - a threat. But like Bonner post 1992, the terrible situation in Bahrain threatens to wither away into aberration and out of Western focus. This would allow the Bahraini authorities to get away with the atrocities and injustice the Libyan and Syrian governments are also accused of perpetrating.

I have intended to point out here how self-interest and ideology plays a bigger role than principle in determining Western policy and manufacturing public consent, rather than give my standpoint on the actual situations in Libya, Syria and Bahrain (let the people in those countries decide how they want to be run). The fact that the West would claim that principles play the main role is hypocrisy to the extreme and acts just as a ploy to hide its true agenda. Mind you, the West is not alone in doing this. In the end, those who genuinely hold principles, even if they are like Bonner and apply them unevenly, will lose out to those who stand to profit in our disposable society.

06 December 2010

Our man in Moscow - Burns, and his Caucasus reports

Check out the detailed insights in the intrigue and background to the current situation in Chechnya and the overall Northern Caucasus region of Southern Russia, written by our Dagestani wedding novelist and clued-up US diplomat William Burns.

This link is of the cable sent after Chechnya's boy president and 'man with the golden gun' Ramzan Kadyrov celebrated his first 100 days of rule. Best line is how Kadyrov is proved clearly to be the strongest figure in the Caucasus because when his 10-year old nephew crashed a car he was driving and lay in a coma, notables from all over felt it necessary to make the pilgrimage to Chechnya's capital Groznyy to condole with Kadyrov. Yes, a 10 year old driving!

This link gives an exhaustive account to the background and current situation in Chechnya. I have to say that Burns does know his stuff. I just hope that the US State Department are listening to him here.
My question is... what is to be embarrassed here about??

04 December 2010

Dagestani wedding - a novel?

If only it was a novel. If one thing that the latest WikiLeaks publication of US embassy cables have shown, there are some budding novelists working for the US Department of State. One cable in particular which has caught the attention of Caucasus watchers is this one detailing the intrigue at the wedding of a local bigwig's son from Russia's southern, majority-Muslim republic of Dagestan. Fascinating reading! Really, Mr Burns the US diplomat should ditch his job and turn to novel writing. It also shows that western diplomatic attitudes and understanding of not just the Caucasus but of any place west of Venice is still stuck in the 19th Century imperialism as the clichéd observations and patronising descriptions in the following 'prose' attest:

Thursday, 31 August 2006, 06:39
SUBJECT: A CAUCASUS WEDDING
Classified By: Deputy Chief of Mission Daniel A. Russell

Summary
-------
Weddings are elaborate in Dagestan, the largest autonomy in the North Caucasus. On August 22 we attended a wedding in Makhachkala, Dagestan's capital: Duma member and Dagestan Oil Company chief Gadzhi Makhachev's son married a classmate. The lavish display and heavy drinking concealed the deadly serious North Caucasus politics of land, ethnicity, clan, and alliance. The guest list spanned the Caucasus power structure -- guest starring Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov -- and underlined just how personal the region's politics can be. End Summary.
Dagestani weddings are serious business: a forum for showing respect, fealty and alliance among families; the bride and groom themselves are little more than showpieces. Weddings take place in discrete parts over three days. On the first day the groom's family and the bride's family simultaneously hold separate receptions. During the receptions the groom leads a delegation to the bride's reception and escorts her back to his own reception, at which point she formally becomes a member of the groom's family, forsaking her old family and clan. The next day, the groom's parents hold another reception, this time for the bride's family and friends, who can "inspect" the family they have given their daughter to. On the third day, the bride's family holds a reception for the groom's parents and family.
Father of the Groom
-------------------
On August 22, Gadzhi Makhachev married off his 19 year-old son Dalgat to Aida Sharipova. The wedding in Makhachkala, which we attended, was a microcosm of the social and political relations of the North Caucasus, beginning with Gadzhi's own biography. Gadzhi started off as an Avar clan leader. Enver Kisriyev, the leading scholar of Dagestani society, told us that as Soviet power receded from Dagestan in the late 1980s, the complex society fell back to its pre-Russian structure. The basic structural unit is the monoethnic "jamaat", in this usage best translated as canton or commune. The ethnic groups themselves are a Russian construct: faced with hundreds of jamaats, the 19th century Russian conquerors lumped cantons speaking related dialects together and called them Avar, Dargin, etc. to reduce the number of "nationalities" in Dagestan to 38. Ever since then, jamaats within each ethnic group have been competing with one another to lead the ethnic group. This competition is especially marked among the Avars, the largest nationality in Dagestan.

As Russian power faded, each canton fielded a militia to defend its people both in the mountains and the capital Makhachkala. Gadzhi became the leader from his home canton of Burtunay, in Kazbek Rayon. He later asserted pan-Avar ambitions, founding the Imam Shamil Popular Front -- named after the great Avar leader of mountaineer resistance to the Russians -- to promote the interests of the Avars and of Burtunay's role within the ethnic group. Among his exploits was a role in the military defense of Dagestan against the 1999 invasion from Chechnya by Shamil Basayev and al-Khattab, and his political defense of Avar villages under pressure in Chechnya, Georgia and Azerbaijan.

Gadzhi has cashed in the social capital he made from nationalism, translating it into financial and political capital -- as head of Dagestan's state oil company and as the single-mandate representative for Makhachkala in Russia's State Duma. His dealings in the oil business -- including close cooperation with U.S. firms -- have left him well off enough to afford luxurious houses in Makhachkala, Kaspiysk, Moscow, Paris and San Diego; and a large collection of luxury automobiles, including the Rolls Royce Silver Phantom in which Dalgat fetched Aida from her parents' reception. (Gadzhi gave us a lift in the Rolls once in Moscow, but the legroom was somewhat constricted by the presence of a Kalashnikov carbine at our feet. Gadzhi has survived numerous assassination attempts, as have most of the still-living leaders of Dagestan. In Dagestan he always travels in an armored BMW with one, sometimes two follow cars full of uniformed armed guards).

Gadzhi has gone beyond his Avar base, pursuing a multi-ethnic cadre policy to develop a network of loyalists. He has sent Dagestani youths, including his sons, to a military type high school near San Diego (we met one graduate, a Jewish boy from Derbent now studying at San Diego state. He has no plans to enter the Russian military).

Gadzhi's multi-ethnic reach illustrates what the editor of the Dagestani paper "Chernovik" told us: that in the last few years the development of inter-ethnic business clans has eroded traditional jamaat loyalties.

But the Avar symbolism is still strong. Gadzhi's brother, an artist from St. Petersburg, ordered as a wedding gift a life-sized statue of Imam Shamil. Shamil is the iconic national symbol, despite his stern and inflexible character (portrayed in Tolstoy's Hadji-Murat as the mountaineers' tyrannical counterpart to the absolutist Tsar). Connection with Shamil makes for nobility among Avars today. Gadzhi often mentions that he is a descendant on his mother's side of Gair-Bek, one of Shamil's deputies.
The Day Before
--------------
Gadzhi's Kaspiysk summer house is an enormous structure on the shore of the Caspian, essentially a huge circular reception room -- much like a large restaurant -- attached to a 40-meter high green airport tower on columns, accessible only by elevator, with a couple of bedrooms, a reception room, and a grotto whose glass floor was the roof of a huge fish tank. The heavily guarded compound also boasts a second house, outbuildings, a tennis court, and two piers out into the Caspian, one rigged with block and tackle for launching jet skis. The house filled up with visitors from all over the Caucasus during the afternoon of August 21. The Chair of Ingushetia's parliament drove in with two colleagues; visitors from Moscow included politicians, businessmen and an Avar football coach. Many of the visitors grew up with Gadzhi in Khasavyurt, including an Ingush Olympic wrestler named Vakha who seemed to be perpetually tipsy. Another group of Gadzhi's boyhood friends from Khasavyurt was led by a man who looked like Shamil Basayev on his day off -- flip-flops, t-shirt, baseball cap, beard -- but turned out to be the chief rabbi of Stavropol Kray. He told us he has 12,000 co-religionists in the province, 8,000 of them in its capital, Pyatigorsk. 70 percent are, like him, Persian-speaking Mountain Jews; the rest are a mixture of Europeans, Georgians and Bukharans.

Also present was Chechnya's Duma member, Khalid (aka Ruslan) Yamadayev, brother of the commander of the notorious Vostok Battalion. He was reserved at the time, but in a follow-up conversation in Moscow on August 29 (please protect) he complained that Chechnya, lacking experts to develop programs for economic recovery, is simply demanding and disposing of cash from the central government. When we pressed him on disappearances, he admitted some took place, but claimed that often parents alleged their children had been abducted when in fact their sons had run off to join the fighters or -- in a case the week before -- they had murdered their daughter in an honor killing. We mentioned the abduction of a widow of Basayev, allegedly to gain access to his money. Khalid said he had not heard of the case, but knew that Basayev had had no interest in wealth; he may have been a religious fanatic, but he was a "normal" person. The fighters who remain are not a serious military force, in Khalid's view, and many would surrender under the proper terms and immunities. He himself is arranging the immunity of a senior official of the Maskhadov era, whose name he would not reveal.

During lunch, Gadzhi took a congratulatory call from Dagestan's president, Mukhu Aliyev. Gadzhi told Aliyev how honored he would be if Aliyev could drop in at the wedding reception. There was a degree of tension in the conversation, which was between two figures each implicitly claiming the mantle of leadership of the Avars. In the event, Aliyev snubbed Gadzhi and did not show up for the wedding, though the rest of Dagestan's political leadership did.

Though Gadzhi's house was not the venue for the main wedding reception, he ensured that all his guests were constantly plied with food and drink. The cooks seemed to keep whole sheep and whole cows boiling in a cauldron somewhere day and night, dumping disjointed fragments of the carcass on the tables whenever someone entered the room. Gadzhi's two chefs kept a wide variety of unusual dishes in circulation (in addition to the omnipresent boiled meat and fatty bouillon). The alcohol consumption before, during and after this Muslim wedding was stupendous. Amidst an alcohol shortage, Gadzhi had flown in from the Urals thousands of bottles of Beluga Export vodka ("Best consumed with caviar"). There was also entertainment, beginning even that day, with the big-name performers appearing both at the wedding hall and at Gadzhi's summer house. Gadzhi's main act, a Syrian-born singer named Avraam Russo, could not make it because he was shot a few days before the wedding, but there was a "gypsy" troupe from St. Petersburg, a couple of Azeri pop stars, and from Moscow, Benya the Accordion King with his family of singers. A host of local bands, singing in Avar and Dargin, rounded out the entertainment, which was constant and extremely amplified.

The main activity of the day was eating and drinking -- starting from 4 p.m., about eight hours worth, all told -- punctuated, when all were laden with food and sodden with drink, with a bout of jet skiing in the Caspian. After dinner, though, the first band started an informal performance -- drums, accordion and clarinet playing the lezginka, the universal dance of the Caucasus. To the uninitiated Westerner, the music sounds like an undifferentiated wall of sound. This was a signal for dancing: one by one, each of the dramatically paunchy men (there were no women present) would enter the arena and exhibit his personal lezginka for the limit of his duration, usually 30 seconds to a minute. Each ethnic group's lezginka was different -- the Dagestani lezginka the most energetic, the Chechen the most aggressive and belligerent, and the Ingush smoother.
Wedding Day 1
-------------
An hour before the wedding reception was set to begin the "Marrakech" reception hall was full of guests -- men taking the air outside and women already filling a number of the tables inside, older ones with headscarves chaperoning dozens of teenaged girls. A Dagestani parliamentarian explained that weddings are a principal venue for teenagers -- and more importantly their parents -- to get a look at one another with a view to future matches. Security was tight -- police presence on the ground plus police snipers positioned on the roof of an overlooking apartment block. Gadzhi even assigned one of his guards as our personal bodyguard inside the reception. The manager told Gadzhi there were seats for over a thousand guests at a time. At the height of the reception, it was standing room only.

At precisely two p.m. the male guests started filing in. They varied from pols and oligarchs of all sorts -- the slick to the Jurassic; wizened brown peasants from Burtunay; and Dagestan's sports and cultural celebrities. Khalid Yamadayev presided over a political table in the smaller of the two halls (the music was in the other) along with Vakha the drunken wrestler, the Ingush parliamentarians, a member of the Federation Council who is also a nanophysicist and has lectured in Silicon Valley, and Gadzhi's cousin Ismail Alibekov, a submariner first rank naval captain now serving at the General Staff in Moscow. The Dagestani milieu appears to be one in which the highly educated and the gun-toting can mix easily -- often in the same person.

After a couple of hours Dalgat's convoy returned with Aida, horns honking. Dalgat and Aida got out of the Rolls and were serenaded into the hall, and into the Makhachev family, by a boys' chorus lining both sides of the red carpet, dressed in costumes aping medieval Dagestani armor with little shields and swords. The couple's entry was the signal for the emcee to roll into high gear, and after a few toasts the Piter (St Petersburg - ed.) "gypsies" began their performance. (The next day one of Gadzhi's houseguests sneered, "Some gypsies! The bandleader was certainly Jewish, and the rest of them were blonde". There was some truth to this, but at least the two dancing girls appeared to be Roma).

As the bands played, the marriageable girls came out to dance the lezginka in what looked like a slowly revolving conga line while the boys sat together at tables staring intently. The boys were all in white shirts and black slacks, while the girls wore a wide variety of multicolored but fashionable cocktail dresses. Every so often someone would shower the dancers with money -- there were some thousand ruble notes but the currency of choice was the U.S. hundred dollar bill. The floor was covered with them; young children would scoop the money up to distribute among the dancers.

Gadzhi was locked into his role as host. He greeted every guest personally as they entered the hall -- failure to do so would cause great insult -- and later moved constantly from table to table drinking toasts with everyone. The 120 toasts he estimated he drank would have killed anyone, hardened drinker or not, but Gadzhi had his Afghan waiter Khan following him around to pour his drinks from a special vodka bottle containing water. Still, he was much the worse for wear by evening's end. At one point we caught up with him dancing with two scantily clad Russian women who looked far from home. One, it turned out was a Moscow poet (later she recited an incomprehensible poem in Gadzhi's honor) who was in town with a film director to write the screenplay for a film immortalizing Gadzhi's defense of Dagestan against Shamil Basayev. By 6 p.m. most of the houseguests had returned to Gadzhi's seaside home for more swimming and more jet-skiing-under-the-influence. But by 8 the summer house's restaurant was full once more, the food and drink were flowing, the name performers were giving acoustic renditions of the songs they had sung at the reception, and some stupendously fat guests were displaying their lezginkas for the benefit of the two visiting Russian women, who had wandered over from the reception.
The Wedding -- Day 2: Enter The Man
------------------------------------
The next day's reception at the Marrakech was Gadzhi's tribute to Aida's family, after which we all returned to a dinner at Gadzhi's summer home. Most of the tables were set with the usual dishes plus whole roast sturgeons and sheep. But at 8:00 p.m. the compound was invaded by dozens of heavily armed mujahedin for the grand entrance of Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov, dressed in jeans and a t-shirt, looking shorter and less muscular than in his photos, and with a somewhat cock-eyed expression on his face. After greetings from Gadzhi, Ramzan and about 20 of his retinue sat around the tables eating and listening to Benya the Accordion King. Gadzhi then announced a fireworks display in honor of the birthday of Ramzan's late father, Ahmat-Hadji Kadyrov. The fireworks started with a bang that made both Gadzhi and Ramzan flinch. Gadzhi had from the beginning requested that none of his guests, most of whom carried sidearms, fire their weapons in celebration. Throughout the wedding they complied, not even joining in the magnificent fireworks display.

After the fireworks, the musicians struck up the lezginka in the courtyard and a group of two girls and three boys -- one no more than six years old -- performed gymnastic versions of the dance. First Gadzhi joined them and then Ramzan, who danced clumsily with his gold-plated automatic stuck down in the back of his jeans (a houseguest later pointed out that the gold housing eliminated any practical use of the gun, but smirked that Ramzan probably couldn't fire it anyway). Both Gadzhi and Ramzan showered the dancing children with hundred dollar bills; the dancers probably picked upwards of USD 5000 off the cobblestones. Gadzhi told us later that Ramzan had brought the happy couple "a five kilo lump of gold" as his wedding present. After the dancing and a quick tour of the premises, Ramzan and his army drove off back to Chechnya. We asked why Ramzan did not spend the night in Makhachkala, and were told, "Ramzan never spends the night anywhere".

After Ramzan sped off, the dinner and drinking -- especially the latter -- continued. An Avar FSB colonel sitting next to us, dead drunk, was highly insulted that we would not allow him to add "cognac" to our wine. "It's practically the same thing", he insisted, until a Russian FSB general sitting opposite told him to drop it. We were inclined to cut the Colonel some slack, though: he is head of the unit to combat terrorism in Dagestan, and Gadzhi told us that extremists have sooner or later assassinated everyone who has joined that unit. We were more worried when an Afghan war buddy of the Colonel's, Rector of the Dagestan University Law School and too drunk to sit, let alone stand, pulled out his automatic and asked if we needed any protection. At this point Gadzhi and his people came over, propped the rector between their shoulders, and let us get out of range. Postscript: The Practical Uses of a Caucasus Wedding
--------------------------------------------- --------
Kadyrov's attendance was a mark of respect and alliance, the result of Gadzhi's careful cultivation -- dating back to personal friendship with Ramzan's father. This is a necessary political tool in a region where difficulties can only be resolved by using personal relationships to reach ad hoc informal agreements. An example was readily to hand: on August 22 Chechnya's parliamentary speaker, Dukvakha Abdurakhmanov, gave an interview in which he made specific territorial claims to the Kizlyar, Khasavyurt and Novolak regions of Dagestan. The first two have significant Chechen-Akkin populations, and the last was part of Chechnya until the 1944 deportation, when Stalin forcibly resettled ethnic Laks (a Dagestani nationality) there. Gadzhi said he would have to answer Abdurakhmanov and work closely with Ramzan to reduce the tensions "that fool" had caused. Asked why he took such statements seriously, he told us that in the Caucasus all disputes revolve around land, and such claims can never be dismissed. Unresolved land claims are the "threads" the Russian center always kept in play to pull when needed. We asked why these claims are coming out now, and were told it was euphoria, pure and simple. After all they had received, the Chechen leadership's feet are miles off the ground. (A well-connected Chechen contact later told us he thought that raising nationalistic irredentism was part of Abdurakhmanov's effort to gain a political base independent from Kadyrov.)

The "horizontal of power" represented by Gadzhi's relationship with Ramzan is the antithesis of the Moscow-imposed "vertical of power". Gadzhi's business partner Khalik Gindiyev, head of Rosneft-Kaspoil, complained that Moscow should let local Caucasians rather than Russians -- "Magomadovs and Aliyevs, not Ivanovs and Petrovs" -- resolve the region's conflicts. The vertical of power, he said, is inapplicable to the Caucasus, a region that Moscow bureaucrats such as PolPred Kozak would never understand. The Caucasus needs to be given the scope to resolve its own problems. But this was not a plug for democracy. Gadzhi told us democracy would always fail in the Caucasus, where the conception of the state is as an extension of the Caucasus family, in which the father's word is law. "Where is the room for democracy in that?" he asked. We paraphrased Hayek: if you run a family as you do a state, you destroy the family. Running a state as you do a family destroys the state: ties of kinship and friendship will always trump the rule of law. Gadzhi's partner agreed, shaking his head sadly. "That's a matter for generations to come", he said.
BURNS
Well, with such a patronising approach and understanding of the Caucasus and the region being reported by its wise diplomats, the US government should not be surprised why it is so hated. Thank you WikiLeaks and to its founder, Australia's own Julian Assange for exposing this!!

Russian built... must be bad!

The term 'Russian-built' is very much a laden term, completely negative in all senses when used by the Western media. Whether it be Russian-made weapons (always used by the bad guys), or Russian-built aircraft or vehicles (crashing and faulty), the ideological, black vs white Cold War imagery still associates anything made in Russia as being intrinsically bad, as if anything in the West must be technically and structurally superior. The latest event to overstress the point is the recent crash of a Dagestan Airlines Tupolev Tu-154 airliner at Moscow's Domodedovo airport. In an incident reminiscent of an accident that occurred with a European-made Air France Airbus 340 2 years ago (by the way, have you ever seen that term 'European-made' before?... Of course not!), the 25 year old plane overran the runway while making an emergency landing and crashed. Unfortunately 2 people died and many were injured, however this is an accident that was not caused because the plane is 'Russian-made'. Such an accident to occur to any aircraft, even US-made Boeing planes, at any time. But why ruin a good story with reason?

The fact remains that these types of accidents in Russia are being attributed to the wrong factors. The political factor to relate bad incidents to the country is quite stark; however, like in most aspects of life, politics gets in the way.

The use of laden terms like 'Russian-built' or 'Chinese-made' is similar to way actors who happen to be gay are referred to as 'gay actors' while their straight colleagues are never labelled 'straight actors'. The insinuation here pigeon holes the actor, or the Russian/Chinese built item of manufacture, into a typecast role, often in a negative light or limited in capacity. It is this type of language which helps instill negative, often propagandistic-based , connotations - something used in all propaganda systems from North Korea and China through to the West.

My condolences go out to the family and friends of those who have been affected by this accident. But remember, this accident could have happened anywhere, at any time.

05 September 2010

Keeping up with the Kadyrovs!

Something that alt-world-watch has a particular fascination with, other than the overuse of the word 'particular', is nepotism, and the accompanying amassing of power and weath this practice bolsters. We would like to believe that this is something only done in 'bad' countries, but it's universal. Just that different countries and societies practise it to different degrees. However there is one place that seems to be in the news, but not, at the same time, which is quietly but surely is set to break world records and score lucrative deals and endorsements in its achievements in this widespread practice.

The Russian republic of Chechnya is, in all intents and purposes, now the private fiefdom of the Kadyrov family ever since the hereditary change of leadership when former Muslim imam and separatist-turned-Moscow-man Akhmed Kadyrov, the leader of Chechnya, was killed in a terrorist attack at the Victory Day parade celebrations in the Chechen capital Groznyy in May 2004, passed power to his thuggish, spoilt and immature son Ramzan, then aged 27. Since then Chechnya has experienced peace and stability, but at a very high cost. With Moscow's blessing, the republic is ruled by the mafia-style showboating and sometime eccentric style of the Kadyrov junior, complete with a cult of personality, grandiose construction projects funded from Chechnya's oil wealth, and massive corruption. At the same time, the Chechens continue living in Third World poverty conditions, enjoying little of the apparent excess lavished to such noticeable signs of wealth like the largest mosque in Europe constructed on the ruins of Groznyy.

Chechnya has had a very violent and extremely tragic history. The region only became a part of the expanding Russian Empire in the early 19th century, after many centuries of superficial Persian and Ottoman Turkish rule. The Russians did not grab full control of the region at first and were engaged in a fifty year campaign to subdue the independent-minded and pious Chechens, earning them the monicker of 'warrior-like'. The Chechens call themselves 'Nokhchii', with the term 'Chechen' applied by the Russians coming from the name of the first Chechen village that they conquered. That proved to be the only lasting feature of Russian conquest on the Chechens as they have always been the unruliest of subjects. When the Russian Empire collapsed in 1917, the Chechens declared their independence, though the Red Army was to later subdue and incorporate them into a 'Northern Caucasus Republic' within the new Russian Soviet Federal Socialist Republic. Again, the Chechens put up stiff resistance to this and continued fighting the Red Army for many years into the late 1920s. Chechen spirit for independence and devotion to Islam conflicted with the Communist ideals that Stalin forcefully imposed on all peoples of the USSR, leading to continued Chechen resistance and, consequently, much repression from the Soviet authorities. When the Nazis invaded the USSR in 1941, one of Hitler's main battle aims was to take Groznyy due to its large oil supplies and willing and anti-Soviet/anti-Russian population. Hitler did send envoys to recruit the Chechens to fight with the Nazis, but nothing came out of it as the Wehrmacht were held up and ultimately defeated in Stalingrad. However, this act of potential Chechen 'treachery' was reason enough for Stalin to deport the entire Chechen population - that's every Chechen person - to Siberia and Central Asia in 1944. Effectively, the Chechens (along with some other ethnicities) were ethnically cleansed from their homeland, and at great expense to the Soviet authorities, as the resources required to undertake such a large campaign involving the forced movement of millions of people could have been better used in more pressing areas such as the Red Army's then push to liberate Eastern Europe during the final stages of World War 2. Having been uprooted from their homeland and almost destroyed as a people, the Chechens were left to rot in barren and remote parts of the USSR until 1957, when part of the Khrushchev's de-Stalinisation programme, he granted the Chechens and other (though not all) uprooted peoples amnesty and free passage back to their ancestral home. Many thousands of Chechens had died from this Moscow-imposed exile, though the survivors did take the offer to return. Nevertheless, the trauma of this exile only added to already high anti-Russian feeling amongst Chechens, and a reason why this feeling is still quite high in Chechnya to this day. Following the collapse of the USSR in late 1991, Chechnya seized the opportunity to declare its independence. Moscow had enough problems dealing with the shock of the fall of such a monolithic system that it left Chechnya alone. However, in an effort to regain some national pride, and to gain some popular support in what otherwise were then sagging ratings for Russian president Yeltsin, while also showing the world that Russia is still a superpower, in December 1994 Moscow launched an assault on Chechnya in an effort to regain control of the region. The Chechens, like all times before, held the Russians down with determined resistance. The Russian response was to quickly make Groznyy live up to its Russian meaning - 'Ugly', destroying this once thriving oil-producing centre. With the war proving to be no walk through the park, the threat of the conflict spreading to neighbouring Russian Muslim regions of Dagestan and Ingushetia, along with the increase of 'terrorist' activity, popular support in Russia for Yeltsin's war was practically nil. It wasn't until 1999 when suspicious attacks on Moscow apartment blocks led to the deaths of about 100 victims lead to a new Russian military assault on Chechnya, all with the public-pleasing intent of avenging the 'terrorists'. This time Chechnya was subdued but at a great cost to the Chechens. So many massacres and human rights violations occurred, though with the 'War on Terror' climate that overcame the World then, these crimes have been conveniently overlooked and forgotten. So there we come to today, where Chechnya is now Kadyrovistan.

The vast scale of nepotism in Chechnya makes the practices current in Central Asia look like examples of the triumph of democracy and human modesty. Having built a mosque on the square named after his father and next to the monument to him, Ramzan Kadyrov continues to create memorials to his ancestors, installing members of his immediate family in the institutions of power as he goes along.

Taking what seems to be a leaf out of the eccentric style of Turkmenistan's late crazy dictator Sapamurad Niyazov Türkmenbashi, last year Chechnya’s Minister of External Relations, National Policy, Press and Information (wow, what a title!) Shamsail Saraliyev announced that Chechnya will soon have televisions, mobile phones and computers marked with the brand name "Aymani", which, coincidentally, is the name of the Chechen president’s mother.

While Kadyrov senior was careful to select a wide range of people to be part of his administration to bring together all warring clans, Junior has gone much further – the system of power he has constructed possesses the features of a mature and fully developed tyranny in which all the rules of transparency have been conveniently tossed out of the window. Basically, he's keeping it in the family. Outdoing Romania's Ceausescu, Razman made his maternal uncle Odes Baysultanov Prime Minister. Soon after, posts also appeared for other close relatives. Ramzan’s sister Zulay holds the post of presidential adviser (i.e. she's gets money for doing nothing, but you need to bribe her if you want something big to be done in Chechnya so she can say good things to her brother). Akhmad-Khadzhi’s brother Magomet Kadyrov is a member of the Chechen parliament. Ramzan’s uncle once removed, Khozh-Akhmed Kadyrov, is chair of the Council of Alims.

But the most important position now goes to mama. Ever determined to show how much he is a mummy's boy, and that means more than just getting a range of electrical goods named after her, Junior has also appointed mama Aynami as head of the Akhmat Kadyrov Regional Charitable Foundation, a body not lacking in funds and run in grand style, often functioning as the sponsor of all kinds of investment projects and programmes connected with the republic’s reconstruction and development. So yet another Evita Peron. How nice!

Ramzan Kadyrov, when not parading around wearing shell suits while driving around in expensive cars, is busy thinking up new and weird ideas. Some of these include proposing that Groznyy be renamed after his father, ordered that all Chechen women wear headscarves and set up a group of teenagers to go around squirting 'immodest women' with waterguns, closed the many refugee camps in Chechnya because they are full of "international spies who are interested in stoking conflict between Chechnya and Russia, who are seeking to destabilize the situation in our region", stated his approval of honour killings, and his own private horse Mourilyan camed third in the 2009 Melbourne Cup - earning him US$380,000. He is also (rightfully) accused of severe human rights abuses, war crimes and corruption, having also been implicated in the extra-judicial shootings of human rights campaigners like Nataliya Estemirova, and opponents like Sulim Yamadaev in Dubai earlier this year.

So what to do? Despite human rights groups doing their best to publicise his crimes, Kadyrov still receives tacit support from Moscow, and indirectly from the West, as he is seen as a plug to the spread of Islamist expansion and terrorism... oh, and because Chechnya has oil. The Chechens are still sufferring under Russian rule, though not directly but at the hands of the family they have placed in power. This cannot last, as the Chechens have always been independent-minded. No matter what 'stability' exists now, Chechnya is just a ticking time bomb. It should have been given its well-deserved independence in 1991. Instead, the situation since has only lent to create what will be a worse fall-out in the future, all to the detriment of the long-suffering Chechens.

Celebrating Paratrooper Day in Moscow... like real men!

Macho men are the same worldwide. Give them booze and a reason and off they go end up getting naked together.

All throughout the former Eastern Bloc, every profession had its own 'day'. So every year there would be a railway workers day, a day for geologists, one for teachers, one for post office workers and so forth. Each division of the armed forces also had their 'day', so there is a paratrooper day, a border guard day etc. The military-specific special days usually end up being excuses for, as what Julia Ioffe wrote on her Moscow Diaries blog:

...drinking, beating up Dagestanis, drinking, storming a cafe and breaking its windows and glassware, driving a tractor onto Red Square (the driver turned out to be a paratrooper poser), drinking, and raiding a watermelon stand. (When bystanders tried to stop them, the paratroopers answered that they were taking “theirs.”)

How charming! However what the paratroopers and border guards love to do most on such a day — other than drink, of course — is frolick. In fountains. In their underwear.

Capturing a glimpse of what fine and esteemed men serve in these important divisions of the military, Russian photo blogger Zyalt took these pictures in Moscow's Gorky Park of the Border Guards having 'fun'




Zyalt has more photos of Paratrooper Day here. These photos are of particular note:

On the band of this man's underwear writes 'Edinnaya Rossiya' (One Russia) i.e. the name of Putin's ruling political party.

That's beer they are drinking here. Beer in many Eastern European countries is sold in plastic bottles just like soft drink. Well, it's only 5% proof, so it's practically soft drink.

However, what was most fitting was that when taking these photos Zyalt was approached by the police and asked, “Are you Russian?” Yes. “Then why are you taking pictures?” What’s the big deal? “Why are you embarrassing Russia?”

01 September 2010

Is Putin 'crude' because he's Russian? Are we in the West then 'proper'?

Here is a significant and much forgotten point that was raised by one commenter in response to a blogpost in the Economist snickering at the 'gutter language' Vladimir Putin uses. It insinuated that Putin's use of 'crude language', akin to Bushisms and Palinisms, reflects on Russia as a whole. Just like the stereotype of Americans being dumb and uncultured, so too must be Russians then, unlike western Europeans. However this is more the truth:

Many comments here erroneously assume that "western" cultural mores in general dictate that one must speak in a prim fashion suitable for a kindergarten at all times. This is hardly the case. Western Europe and America have a long tradition of "earthy" language that would be characterised as "crude" by these individuals.

In fact, this priggish attitude is a purely middle-class concoction - call it bourgeois, if you like. The upper and lower classes had no problem with "coarse" language, though since the 19th century the upper classes have been infected by bourgeois moralising to an extent. This bawlderising of speech became popular in English-speaking countries only in the 19th century as the middle class enlarged and sought to differentiate itself from the working class (whence most of them came) by implementing an exaggeratedly "good" standard of conduct that they thought made them seem more refined and pious and upper-class.

The upper classes were every bit as bawdy as the lower. Read Christopher Marlowe, for example, or Shakespeare. It was only the bourgeois middle classes who ostentatiously sought to parade their morality by proscribing "vulgar" language. It is hardly a "western" more.


With this in mind, this is why old money like George W. Bush seems like a 'common person' in his speech.

30 August 2010

What do the ex-Soviet soldiers who fought in Afghanistan think?

Russian journalist Aleksandr Osipovich recently paid a visit to the one-room museum devoted to the Soviet Union's bitter war in Afghanistan, which lasted from 1979 to 1989, and set the stage for today's conflict between US-led coalition forces and the Taliban. Curator of this museum, which Osipovich descibes as 'one of the humblest in a country full of grand military museums and mounents', is retired colonel Vladimir Kostyuchenko. With very little government help, the museum consists mainly of black-and-white photographs of local Moscow soldiers who died in Afghanistan, many of whom perished in the same places where American soldiers are fighting Taliban insurgents today.

Afghanistan was the Soviet Union's Vietnam. Much like how the USA feared that Vietnam becoming Communist would lead to a 'domino-effect' that the countries of Southeast Asia and then Latin America would follow one-by-one, Moscow feared that the success of the Islamic revolution in Iran in 1979 would lead to a likewise domino-effect with its own Muslim-populated Central Asian republics, and so chose to contain this by supporting a Communist government in Kabul. Many young Soviet soldiers were sent to fight in the difficult terrain of Afghanistan, where many died, while others, like their US counterparts from Vietnam, came back shunned by a public who saw them as losers, and with countless problems. During the war, the Soviet media referred to their soldiers as 'Internationalist-Warriors' while the Mujahadeen, many whose sons are now Taliban, were referred to as dushmani which in Turkic, Persian, Indian and Balkan languages means 'enemy'. However, since their final withdrawal in 1989, very little attention has been made to these veterans, and no significant monument has been made in the ex-USSR dedicated to these poor men.

Since the US-led invasion of Afghanistan in response to 9/11 in October 2001, NATO forces have led a hopeless battle much like the Soviets before them, leading many former Red Army colonels to say with much glee 'well, we couldn't get rid of them, what makes you think you can'. However, as Osipovich writes, Soviet military officers and soldiers who were on the ground in Afghanistan have an interesting take on the present situation:

Despite the growing cost in American lives, US President Barack Obama was right to send tens of thousands more troops to battle the Taliban and al-Qaeda, asserted Kostyuchenko, a former Soviet helicopter pilot who served three tours in Afghanistan in the 1980s. “It would be a total mistake to withdraw forces," he said. "If forces are withdrawn from Afghanistan before normality is restored there, it will be a step backwards and the nest of terrorism will only grow.

“And next time they won't just be destroying buildings somewhere in the United States,” he continued. “They'll be setting off an atomic bomb, maybe in America, or maybe in Russia. And this will be tragic."

In the 1980s, Afghanistan was the site of the last great Cold War confrontation between Moscow and Washington: the CIA funded mujahedeen forces battling the Soviet military, supplying the Afghan resistance fighters with Stingers, the shoulder-held missiles that killed many of Kostyuchenko's fellow helicopter pilots.

Today, veterans of the Soviet war in Afghanistan are in the odd position of cheering on their old enemies, the Americans, in the present-day struggle to contain Islamic extremism -- a mutual enemy that has targeted both Russia and United States.

But given their own painful experience fighting the mujahedeen and trying to prop up a weak government in Kabul, the veterans, known in Russian as Afgantsy, are also deeply pessimistic about US prospects in Afghanistan. "As a military man, I fully understand why the Americans had to send in troops and fight the Taliban, and I support them in this," said Franz Klintsevich, head of the Russian Union of Veterans of Afghanistan, an organization with more than 400,000 members throughout the country.

Still, the United States seems doomed to fail in Afghanistan, said Klintsevich, who is also a member of parliament from Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's ruling United Russia party. "This is a situation with no exit," he said, seated in a leather chair at his office at the State Duma building in central Moscow. "That's a fact. Obama's steps are totally correct, but it's still a situation with no exit."

Klintsevich, 53, served in Afghanistan from 1986 to 1988 and had an unusual career for a Soviet officer. Before his deployment, he studied Dari, a language spoken by many Afghans, at a specialised military academy. On the ground, he held talks with mujahedeen factions, often risking his life to meet local resistance leaders in mud-walled homes and broker temporary truces.

It was an experience that gave him an unusually clear view of Afghan society - and the daunting difficulties that the Soviets faced. "After roughly half a year, I understood that we would not achieve anything," Klintsevich said.

The Obama administration has ramped up troop levels and pledged to wage a major offensive against the Taliban before starting to draw down forces in July 2011. Although Obama's strategy has come under fire at home from both left and right, Klintsevich said he agreed with its basic logic. "You need to deliver a serious, incapacitating blow. And then, gradually, while strengthening the local authorities, you need to leave," he said.

Klintsevich argues that the United States and Russia are jointly responsible for the tragedy of Afghanistan, which has experienced near-constant strife since the Soviet invasion of 1979. While the Soviets triggered the war, he said, the Americans escalated it by lavishing funds on the mujahedeen, among whom were found future terrorists like Osama bin Laden.

Now the two former Cold War foes are stuck with the monster they created. "Over the 10 years that we were in Afghanistan, a generation of people grew up at war. This is an entire generation that learned nothing except how to hold a gun and shoot and get paid for it. They received this money, above all, from abroad," Klintsevich said.

"In 1979, thanks to our joint efforts, we let the genie out of the bottle, and putting him back in is impossible. We can only fight him. And we need to fight him together."

There is little about geopolitics in Vladimir Kostyuchenko's museum, which is located on the ground floor of an apartment building in southeast Moscow. Groups of children come here sometimes to see the exhibits, which include handmade papier-mâché mannequins of Soviet soldiers and a mujaheeden fighter. Other times, local veterans come here to socialize and reminisce.

Many Afgantsy suffered post-traumatic stress disorder and had trouble readjusting to society, especially in the chaos that followed the collapse of the Soviet Union. "A lot of them started drinking and drank themselves to death. … Or people took up crime. They knew how to shoot and fight, so they became killers," Kostyuchenko said.

The small gatherings in Kostychenko's museum help veterans get by. "It's a family," he said. "We come together and talk to each other and it makes us feel better."


It's clear that Afgantsy support for NATO operations in Afghanistan gives some sort of justification and reason for their own actions 20-30 years before, which if this is a view held by others in ex-USSR society, this could be a catalyst for the re-acceptance of these veterans much like how the Vietnam War veterans in the USA and allied countries like Australia were able to accept them two decades after their return from their own hell on earth.

Below, extract from a Soviet Army guide from the 1980s warning 'Internationalist-Warriors' are banned from forming unsanctioned contacts with the locals

23 August 2010

When all else fails, smear

I was wondering when they were going to sully Wikileaks founder, Julian Assange. It didn't take long. Apparently he raped in Sweden (where the Wikileaks server is located), so the news was splashed around the world. Apparently the charges have quietly been downgraded to 'molestation', but you only need to ask Michael Jackson's publicist that even if these accusations are not true, the damage done to image is itself more than enough. The thing I am most surprised is that 'they' didn't try to ping him with a paedophilia charge - a stigma no one can get over.

When I saw this news, it first reminded me of the supposed dirty tactics that those naughty 'un-democratic' countries use when they go after their dissidents. Anwar Ibrahim of Malaysia, for instance, the former right-hand man to Dr. Mahatir turned leading opposition leader has been facing constant court charges for sodomy, in a case which the Western media (rightfully) portray as a set-up to discredit and destroy the image of Malaysia's number one dissident. I also thought of the likes of former Yukos boss Mikhail Khodorkovskii in Russia who is in jail for tax evasion. The West make him to be a hero of democracy and a victim of trumped-up charges and misjustice when his charges are actually legitimate. The only thing in his case is that if Khodorkovskii is jailed for tax evasion, then so should all the rest of Russia's oligarchs. However, the Russian establishment showed that they have such dirt on all of Russia's rich and powerful so if they do try to rock the boat, it won't be hard to charge them with something. Essentially, what is happening with Assange is something we associate with a place like mean Russia, when yet again, the West does the same. This adds yet another example of malpractice that countries like Russia will use as an example of 'yeah, but we are only doing what you do' when levelled with some Western criticism about its supposed Soviet-style actions.

If this is an elaborate but ultimately poorly managed smear campaign by the CIA, well, they do forget or just plainly cannot see beyond a US political mindset in that what might constitute a career-destroying public humiliation in the US does not necessarily have the same dire consequences elsewhere. Sometimes it is quite the opposite. Case in point was the CIA in the 1960s seeking to destroy Indonesia's anti-imperialist first president Sukarno, at a time when his opposition to the West had earned him massive support at home as well as a budding relationship with the Soviet Union. The CIA thought capturing some images of Sukarno having sex with a woman who was not his wife and then distributing them would attract the scorn of Muslim Indonesia. Well who had egg on their face? The result was a huge disaster for the CIA as rather than creating a mass scandal, Sukarno's prowess as a guy getting the chicks led to his already massive popularity grow to even higher levels. Machismo beats Islam in Indonesia. With Assange's case, just the mere accusation of rape would have destroyed him in US circumstances, but elsewhere, the belief of innocent until proven guilt has a higher chance of prevailing, especially considering the rather murky circumstances these charges have been made and then quickly dropped. Still, I am sure some damage is done, if only the likes of Fox News will probably refer to him as an 'accused rapist' from now on.

The bottom line is that we are quick to judge supposedly repressive societies using dirty tricks and blackmail to control dissent, all in a smug sense of Western moral superiorty, when in actual fact the West uses the same tactics on its dissidents such as Julian Assange. This certainly puts a spotlight on whether we are truly 'free' as they would like us to believe?

24 July 2010

Miss Russia is covered in bling

Miss Russia, known also by her mortal name Irina Antonenko, will soon depart for Las Vegas to represent her country in the Miss Universe competition. In her suitcase is a custom-designed dress embroidered in gold, becrusted with sapphires and amethysts, and, sorry to say Pamela Anderson, trimmed in sable fur. It is supposed to resemble the old tsars’ crown, ye olde Monomakh’s Cap. Total cost? US$60,000.

But if you think that is extravagence, then check this out. In 2006, when the now-bankrupt Greece was living high on the hog with other people's funny money, it hosted the Eurovision Song Contest. Their representative that year was Anna Vissi, left, who wore this Jean Paul Gaultier outfit. How much did Greek public broadcaster pay for this disaster of an ensemble? €200,000, no less. Please charge it to Germany, efharisto para poly.

20 July 2010

Russian rocker latest darling of West

Yuri Shevchuk, legendary rock star famous for fronting the cult Soviet-era rock band DDT, has had a lot of press lately in the West over his opposition to Putin and how he is being excluded from TV and radio, in a pattern much like he faced during Soviet times. The West is using this as yet another example of how Putin's Russia is USSR 2.0. The reality is that it is true that Shevchuk is being shunned, but he is not unique nor is this purely a Russian phenomenon. As I have mentioned briefly in previous posts, just like under the former Communist regimes as today, political patronage is the most important factor to building a music career not only in Russia but in practically all former Eastern bloc countries undergoing democratisation. The Shevchuk experience is also being faced by artists in countries allied to the West such as Georgia, Ukraine and even current EU members.

While most musicians, singers and actors in the West are and can be apolitical, in the Eastern bloc that is just not possible. As a layover from Communist times when good politicial credentials was the main prerequisite for a long and fruitful career, the same still applies. That there is multi-party politics in most former Eastern bloc countries makes it even riskier than before. A singer must carefully chose for which political party he/she will sing for at politicial rallies during election campaigns. If that party wins and enters into government, expect to appear on TV quite a bit. On the otherhand, if a singer is identified with an opposition party, quite often they will face a difficult time appearing on TV, getting advertising and face punitive bureaucratic hassles. A firm example of making and breaking political patronage in Eastern Europe came with Ukraine's selection of its representative for Eurovision this year. At first the relatively unknown singer Vasyl Lazarovych was announced as Ukraine's singer and that a competition would be held to pick a song for him. Lazarovych happened to be close friends with the government-appointed Director of the Ukrainian national broadcasting station, the organisation responsible for Ukraine's selection for Eurovision. When elections in March saw the pro-Western Yushchenko government ousted for pro-Russian parties led by Yanukovych, as is often the case with political appointees, the Ukrainin TV director was quickly replaced with a new person close to the new government. Also to go was Lazarovych as a supposed anti-corruption measure (Lazarovych was selected as he would self-fund his Eurovision campaign), but most people in Eastern Europe saw the real reason for this sacking of sorts was that he was too closely identified as a Yushchenko supporter. A new competition to select a new song was quickly organised, heavily featuring singers who had been sidelined under the previous government and consequently sung on the election campaign for political parties that eventually formed the new government. Another obscure singer won the competition and went on to sing at Eurovision.

Ukraine is not alone in having had politically motivated selections for representatives. Bulgaria's singer at Eurovision 2008 worked as an assistant to the head of Bulgarian National TV and was an member of the youth wing of the then ruling Socialist Party. Macedonia's 2000 entry featured the cat screeching of 'I lurve you a hundert persent yes ay du' by XXL, a girl band whose members happen to be the daughters of high ranking functionaries tied to Macedonia's then ruling party. While the Serbo-Montenegrin entrants in 2005, 6 boys hoddled together as boy band 'No Name' were all sons of businessmen with very close relations with the sleazy and very corrupt Montenegrin president Milo Djukanović.

As always, politics and music go hand in hand. It's no surprise that many of Russia's top singers of Russia happen also to be members of Putin's Edinnaya Rossiya (United Russia) party, much like how many were Communist Party members back in the day. In Serbia, the pink-haired turbofolk singer Zorica Brunclik will always be associated with her membership in the much despised JUL party led by Milošević's wife Mira Marković. Being close to the ruling family awarded Brunclik with heavy exposure on the government controlled media, a string many surprising number one hits and even a short stint as Minister of Culture. After Milošević was toppled in October 2000, so too did Brunclik's profile and career, disappearing from public sight due to her close connections with the old regime and not daring to reappear on the idiot box until many years later, and that being only on local provincial stations. Brunclik recently appeared on a celebrity reality TV show, helping her to resurrect her career, though she had to face a barrage of criticism due to her past political allegiances while being followed by the cameras.

Now don't think that all this only applies to the Eastern Bloc. Country stars the Dixie Chicks faced a major backlash after their very public opposition to the US invasion of Iraq and disapproval of George W. Bush. The US government were not behind this, but many political elements close to the then administration were responsible for villifying the country music band.

Relatively speaking, it would have been better if Shevchuk was the unique case that the Western media would like us to believe. However, the reality is that in any political system, if you want to go far, best toe the line.

16 July 2010

There's nothing like gunning for the hometown girl

Miss Russian Spy 2010 Anna Chapman may be getting the attention of straight men, losing her UK citizenship, and is currently being treated to a grilling session by Russian intelligence, but her heroic home town of Volgograd (formerly Stalingrad) just loves the local girl. In a truly Russian response to her new found celebrity, there is talk of putting her on the ballot for the Russian parliament (United Russia, Putin's party, naturally) and local authorities have launched a contest for a song in praise of Annushka. I can't wait to hear it! Also, apparently Anna's first husband was a presenter on an 'erotic TV channel' in the UK. Ooer!

14 July 2010

Moya Rodina!

That's 'My Motherland' in Russian. Evgenii Ross, a popular Russian shanson singer, gathered togethered some of his colleagues to sing praise to mama Russia. Here's the clip...

Well, it's your typical patriotic bash of a song. No doubt this will be sung at 'United Russia' rallies, (Putin's political party) which somehow seems to have all of Russia's top celebrities as members, much like in USSR times when they were Communist Party members. The most intriguing lyric in the song is 'Ot Rasputina do Putina', translated is From Rasputin to Putin. I don't know if it's because of the rhyme but what a link to make.

12 July 2010

Speedy justice for 'spies', not Wall Street

I have refused to write any more about the farcical and quite dubious Russian 'spy' scandal as I don't want to justify or legitimise its existence with comment. However, as Danny Schechter of Consortium News reports, if only Wall Street plunderers could be treated as aggressively as the handful of Russian "sleeper agents" who were caught, processed and exiled back to Russia in a few days - as long as the Wall Street tycoons could be separated from their money, too.

Instead, the architects of the global financial collapse have been picked up by the U.S. taxpayers, who then were made to dust off the designer suits so the tycoons could get back to collecting out-sized salaries and bonuses, as Danny Schechter notes in this guest essay:

We just witnessed justice on steroids. Ten Russian “spies” — even if we still don’t know what they were spying on or why — were brought to court, copped a plea, and were on their way out of the country by midnight.

Check out what more insightful things he has to say here.