Showing posts with label Control. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Control. Show all posts

08 December 2010

The lawless Wild West attacks WikiLeaks

Excellent piece by Glenn Greenwald how the West silences its dissidents using intimidation and a whole variety of actions beyond the rule of law. Here is part of what he had to comment about the worrying situation.

Just look at what the U.S. Government and its friends are willing to do and capable of doing to someone who challenges or defies them -- all without any charges being filed or a shred of legal authority. They've blocked access to their assets, tried to remove them from the Internet, bullied most everyone out of doing any business with them, froze the funds marked for Assange's legal defense at exactly the time that they prepare a strange international arrest warrant to be executed, repeatedly threatened him with murder, had their Australian vassals openly threaten to revoke his passport, and declared them "Terrorists" even though - unlike the authorities who are doing all of these things - neither Assange nor WikiLeaks ever engaged in violence, advocated violence, or caused the slaughter of civilians.

This is all grounded in the toxic mindset expressed yesterday on Meet the Press (without challenge, naturally) by Republican Sen. Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, who said of Assange: "I think the man is a high-tech terrorist. He’s done an enormous damage to our country, and I think he needs to be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. And if that becomes a problem, we need to change the law." As usual, when wielded by American authorities, the term "terrorist" means nothing more than: "those who impede or defy the will of the U.S. Government with any degree of efficacy." Anyone who does that is, by definition, a Terrorist. And note McConnell's typical, highly representative view that if someone he wants to punish isn't a criminal under the law, then you just "change the law" to make him one.

But that sort of legal scheming isn't even necessary. The U.S. and its "friends" in the Western and business worlds are more than able and happy to severely punish anyone they want without the slightest basis in "law." That's what the lawless, Wild Western World is: political leaders punishing whomever they want without any limits, certainly without regard to bothersome concepts of "law." Anyone who doubts that should just look at what has been done to Wikileaks and Assange over the last week. In this series of events, there are indeed genuine and pernicious threats to basic freedom and security; they most assuredly aren't coming from WikiLeaks or Julian Assange.

People often have a hard time believing that the terms "authoritarian" and "tyranny" apply to their own government, but that's because those who meekly stay in line and remain unthreatening are never targeted by such forces. The face of authoritarianism and tyranny reveals itself with how it responds to those who meaningfully dissent from and effectively challenge its authority: do they act within the law or solely through the use of unconstrained force?



Greenwald goes on to mention how the American mainstream media quickly followed the official line by no longer describing WikiLeaks as a 'whistleblower' website. Greenwald also added:

Just to underscore the climate of lawless initmidation that has been created: before WikiLeaks was on many people's radars (i.e., before the Apache video release), I wrote about the war being waged on them by the Pentagon, interviewed Assange, and urged people to donate money to them. In response, numerous people asked - both in comments and via email - whether they would be in danger, could incur legal liability for providing material support to Terrorism or some other crime, if they donated to WikiLeaks. Those were American citizens expressing that fear over an organization which had never been remotely charged with any wrongdoing.

Similarly, I met several weeks ago with an individual who once worked closely with WikiLeaks, but since stopped because he feared that his country - which has a very broad extradition treaty with the U.S. - would arrest him and turn him over to the Americans upon request. He knew he had violated no laws, but given that he's a foreigner, he feared - justifiably - that he could easily be held by the United States without charges, denied all sorts of basic rights under the Patriot Act, and otherwise be subject to a system of "justice" which recognizes few limits or liberties, especially when dealing with foreigners accused of aiding Terrorists.

All the oppressive, lawless policies of the last decade - lawless detention, Guantanamo, disappearing people to CIA black sites, rendition, the torture regime, denial of habeas corpus, drones, assassinations, private mercenary forces, etc. - were designed, first and foremost, to instill exactly this fear, to deter any challenge. Many of these policies continue, and that climate of fear thus endures. As the treatment just thus far of WikiLeaks and Assange demonstrates, that reaction -though paralyzing and counter-productive - is not irrational. And one thing is for sure: there is nothing the U.S. Government could do - no matter how lawless or heinous - which (with rare exception) would provoke the objections of the American establishment media.


Fear and intimidation - the tools of an authoritarian ruling elite. These are the insinuations levelled at countries like Russia, China and Iran. But it is obvious that the West employs the same control tools... just in a more sophisticated way.

04 December 2010

On with the theme... Airbus bad, Boeing good!

Much has been reported about the engine problems that a Qantas Airbus A380 faced soon after taking off from Singapore bound for Sydney at the beginning of November 2010. Logic had it that this was yet another problem in a long line of incidents facing the world's largest passenger aircraft. The UK media at first fell into line with the negative reporting on the A380; however once it was discovered the problem lay with the British-built Rolls Royce engines (lucky they weren't Russian - refer to the previous post for details), the negativity was reduced and replaced with more optimistic reporting of solutions to be found quickly.

I am extremely suspicious of this event. As I have reported previously, the Airbus A380 has unfairly been receiving negative press, while its conceptual rival, the US-built Boeing 787 constantly is praised as the way forward. What is reported is far from reality. What does not get reported as prominently is that the Boeing 787 is now 3 years behind schedule and this is due to the fact that in testing its performance is not living up to what was promised. Namely, the Boeing 787, with its lightweight structure and state-of-the-art technology, will provide 20% less fuel consumption and extremely long flights. Boeing's rationale was that the future will be frequency over capacity, which is much how the US airlines maintain their flight operations. Also, it would open the opportunity for airlines to actually afford to operate point-to-point flights. Boeing sold the idea that the Boeing 787 would be able to fly, for instance, New York to Jakarta non-stop. Using current aircraft, either their size do not warrant such a non-stop flight or make it cost-effective. Airbus saw things differently saw that there would be a big need in future to move more people between hub airports (such as London and Singapore) from where passengers can connect onto smaller aircraft to lesser destinations.

For the past few years, airline specialists have been monitoring to see which out of the two concepts will succeed. I personally believe that Airbus has the best policy, on an operational basis. The main problem facing airports such as London's Heathrow these days is capacity. There simply is not enough time in the day using the current airport infrastructure to afford the luxury of having many smaller aircraft flying at high frequency to far-off places as what the Boeing 787 supposedly offers. Taking into account that there is increasing public hostility to building new airports or expanding existing ones, such a operation model just won't work in the future. The way that Airbus sees it will be the way. Instead of having 5 planes heading off from an airport like London Heathrow to 5 different destinations in South East Asia, two Airbus A380s can fly to Singapore, from where passengers can transfer to smaller destinations, reducing the amount of aircraft in the air on a time ratio, which means that less congestion at airports and less pollution. Essentially, in a perfect world, it would be better if there were more direct flights as what the B787 would offer because there's less hassle for passengers; however this is just not fitting with actual circumstances. On a more symbolic aspect, the B787 is an American vision of the triumph of individualism while the Airbus approach is more collectivist, placing the common good before the selfishness of the individual.
However, the best concept doesn't always win. Beta was superior in quality to VHS, but we all know who won out. Good marketing and/or sledging opponents wins out. And that is what we are witnessing here. It seems like that Boeing has a far better marketing system whereby the world's media are practically in their pockets emphasising Airbus's faults while concealing those of the Boeing 787.

What has been interesting to note is the near absence of any negative reporting on the Boeing 787 despite experiencing far greater problems than the Airbus A380! The best example of this was this report on the BBC website whereby the CEO of Qatar Airways labelled the Dreamliner 'a failure', which is far damning that any comment made about its Airbus rival. However, rather than being given headline coverage, it was only to be found in the rather obscure 'Aerospace' section of their website far from the World's conscience. This is despite the fact, as already mentioned, that the project is already 3 years behind (actually it is much later than that - the launch customer ANA of Japan should have received their planes back in 2005!) and that in testing one of the 787s actually caught on fire! This is scandalous! Had the A380 caught on fire during testing, I'm sure we wouldn't have heard the end of it, much like how its engines caught on fire on the Qantas flight. The fire was due to the flammable nature of the revolutionary composite materials used and the wiring problems the 787 has been facing ever since testing started. It was also quite apparent that the amazing performance statistics touted for the aircraft will not be met, therefore for all of its supposed innovations and new technology, Boeing has created a plane no different from those already on the market. Precisely, as Akbar Al Baker of Qatar Airways said, this plane is a failure. But how come it is the Airbus A380 which is being associated with failure instead?

Some in aviation circles allude to conspiracy theories pointing to US efforts to undermine the A380 due to a bruised ego of no longer having the largest passenger aircraft in the world: the iconic Boeing 747. As much as I would like to be optimistic that such playground behaviour would not be a factor, considering the uneven reporting of these two aircraft, I am inclined to believe that this bruised ego does play a big role. This was evident with the lack of readiness of major US airports such as at Los Angeles and New York to accommodate the A380, despite being given the same time as other airports in other parts of the world who were ready for such large aircraft years before they entered service in 2007. The US attitude was that by using such delay tactics, along with a negative local media campaign, will show how such a European plane is not practical. It was almost successful at the beginning; for instance the busy Los Angeles Airport had to come to a complete standstill whenever an A380 took off or landed as no infrastructure changes such as widening taxi lanes were made. This disruption almost led to either A380 operators threatening to cancel their services to Los Angeles, or other airlines redirecting their planes to other airports in the LA area.

All new products, whether they are huge aeroplanes or small household items, experience teething problems, hence why testing actually happens. But the problems associated with this process should not be mixed with national pride. As the reporting on the problems facing the A380 and B787 show, there is no level playing field here. However, we pride ourselves over places like North Korea of being transparent and just... I don't see it here
There's another suspicious aspect to this Qantas A380 saga. Australia's flag carrier is known foremost as the world's safest airline, something even mentioned in films like Rainman. Qantas also has been a very profitable airline, thanks mainly to streamlining operations and an ability to fill its planes. This in turn has made the airline quite attractive to speculators and equity groups. In 2006, an ostensibly Australian entity owned by a consortium of US equity groups tried staging a share takeover of the airline causing much fear in Australia that, like in previous experiences when airlines have been taken over by such groups, Qantas would be stripped of its assets and attributes while outsourcing operations so as to cut costs and generate greater profit yields. Fortunately US insularity saved the day when the proposal to stage the takeover was handed in past the deadline as the Americans did not factor the 18 hour time difference between themselves and Australia! However, it seems a bit too coincidental that since then the amount and extent the media reports of Qantas accidents and incidents have been excessive, especially relative to other airlines such as more accident and delay-prone Virgin Blue and Tiger Airways. All this excessive negative reporting seems to be pointing towards a concerted plan to drive Qantas' share prices downwards, allowing for the stage to be set for another takeover attempt in the near future.

This is all speculation at the moment, though I find it hard that when Virgin Blue has an accident we hear nothing, but if something happens when a Qantas flight is delayed due to the discovery of a faulty part, it's top news. Qantas is the victim of its own meticulous attention to safety and keeping passengers informed. Many other airlines would just use some smokescreen excuse to hide such an incident to passengers.

But what all this shows is that dishonesty and concealment wins the day.

20 July 2010

The US Right's power of infrastructure

From Consortium News, a very insightful article by Robert Parry, the American journalist who exposed the Iran-Contra Affair in the 1980s of how right-wing forces have built an elaborate and unaccountable infrastructure network to ensure prolonged rule:

Dwight Eisenhower, after commanding Allied forces in World War II and serving eight years as U.S. President, came to appreciate the power of political and economic infrastructure, leading to his famous warning about the threat to the American Republic from a “military-industrial complex.”

Yet, in the years since Eisenhower’s Farewell Address in 1961, the U.S. political system has allowed the “military-industrial complex” to continue growing and, indeed, to evolve into a sophisticated organism that collaborates with a supportive propaganda arm of think tanks, political apologists and media outlets, further distorting American democracy.

This infrastructure expanded sharply in the early 1980s when President Ronald Reagan secured a massive military buildup (despite the fact that America’s Soviet adversary was already crumbling) and pushed for a “pro-democracy” apparatus using both public and private funds.

Though Reagan’s “democracy” promotion ostensibly worked to undermine anti-U.S. governments abroad, the apparatus – ranging from the federal National Endowment for Democracy to the quasi-private Freedom House – became, in effect, a jobs program for neoconservatives, giving them a base of income, access and respectability within Official Washington.

Also, coinciding with Reagan’s presidency was the construction of a right-wing media machine that propagated Reagan’s political philosophy and attacked public figures, both in politics and in journalism, who refused to get in line. In the three decades since Reagan came to power, this media machine has grown into one of the most feared forces in American political life.

Reagan’s creation and expansion of these interlocking and self-interested institutions set the stage for the next explosive growth of the national security bureaucracy, after the 9/11 terror attacks.

Cheered on by influential neocons (and think tanks) and supported by the right-wing news media, President George W. Bush had no trouble erecting a new national security infrastructure that rose quickly from the already well-funded foundation of the U.S. intelligence community.

The expansion was dramatic. In less than a decade, the estimated $30 billion a year intelligence budget more than doubled to $75 billion, a figure that doesn’t count many related military and counter-terrorism operations.

In a landmark investigative article, the Washington Post attempted to quantify this mind-numbing expansion. According to Post reporters Dana Priest and William M. Arkin, this “Top-Secret America” represents “an alternative geography of the United States” with clusters of highly classified government agencies scattered around the country though concentrated most heavily in the Washington area. (I'd like to add that this had been reported years before - me)

The first article, entitled “A hidden world, growing beyond control,” highlighted the key findings:

“The top-secret world the government created in response to the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, has become so large, so unwieldy and so secretive that no one knows how much money it costs, how many people it employs, how many programs exist within it or exactly how many agencies do the same work. …

“After nine years of unprecedented spending and growth, the result is that the system put in place to keep the United States safe is so massive that its effectiveness is impossible to determine.

“The investigation's other findings include:

“* Some 1,271 government organizations and 1,931 private companies work on programs related to counterterrorism, homeland security and intelligence in about 10,000 locations across the United States.

“* An estimated 854,000 people, nearly 1.5 times as many people as live in Washington, D.C., hold top-secret security clearances.

“* In Washington and the surrounding area, 33 building complexes for top-secret intelligence work are under construction or have been built since September 2001. Together they occupy the equivalent of almost three Pentagons or 22 U.S. Capitol buildings - about 17 million square feet of space.

“* Many security and intelligence agencies do the same work, creating redundancy and waste. For example, 51 federal organizations and military commands, operating in 15 U.S. cities, track the flow of money to and from terrorist networks.

“* Analysts who make sense of documents and conversations obtained by foreign and domestic spying share their judgment by publishing 50,000 intelligence reports each year - a volume so large that many are routinely ignored.”

In other words, President Bush launched a crash program to create a massive infrastructure dedicated to fighting the so-called Long War against Islamic militancy. But the size of the endeavor was so vast and its construction so hasty and haphazard that it may not actually be adding to the national security.

But what this Top-Secret America is sure to do is to fight aggressively to maintain its jobs, money and power. In that, it will be aided by its key allies in the complementary institutions of the old “military-industrial complex,” the neocon “democracy” infrastructure, and the right-wing media. Other potent groups, such as the Republican Party and the Israel Lobby, will help, too.

The combination of these factors – especially when weighed against the relatively weak and severely underfunded counter-forces of America’s progressives and independent media – suggests that a meaningful democracy may no longer exist in the United States.

Many on the Left have fumed about President Barack Obama’s failure to reverse Bush’s national security policies. However, if one examines the relative power factors, it would probably amount to political suicide for Obama or any national leader to try to dismantle these interlocking infrastructures.

While the Right has worked diligently over the past several decades to strengthen its institutions and influence, the American Left has marginalized itself, choosing to possess no media outlets or think tanks that even come close to rivaling what the Right has in multiplicity.

For instance, wealthy progressives allowed the liberal talk-radio network Air America – a modest effort to balance the Right’s enormous advantage in talk radio – to collapse this year. Meanwhile, worthy Internet sites go begging, while the right-wingers keep adding and adding to their media assets.

(Further revealing the asymmetry of today’s American media, right-wing Newsmax, run by conspiracy theorist Christopher Ruddy, has put in a bid to buy the Washington Post Co.’s financially troubled Newsweek. Though best known as an Internet site, Newsmax already publishes a national magazine.)

Besides the Left’s benign neglect toward institutions needed to fight a “war of ideas” with the Right, there is also the cumulative impact of the ever-expanding military-intelligence-neocon arsenals that can level almost any political adversary who poses a significant threat. “Themes” knocking down a political enemy can be put into play instantaneously and will quickly reverberate through the Right's media echo chamber into the mainstream press.

Allied corporate interests also can now fund attack ads almost without restrictions, thanks to a ruling by the right-wing-dominated U.S. Supreme Court last January. [See Consortiumnews.com’s “Democracy’s End of the Road.”]

On an individual level, fewer and fewer professionals in Washington will dare take on this fearsome complex of interlocking infrastructures, what might be called a new Iron Triangle comprised of wealthy military/intelligence contractors, neocon ideologues and right-wing media outlets.

Official Washington – both in media and politics – will become even more deaf to the needs of average Americans. After all, a corollary to Eisenhower’s “military-industrial-complex” warning could be Upton Sinclair’s old truism that “it is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.”

With so much money on one side and so little on the other, few professionals would be willing to put principles over their pocketbooks.

As noble as it might be to fight the good fight without resources, in the real world, that is simply a recipe for failure – especially when the other side has a war chest in the billions of dollars and growing by the day.