Showing posts with label geopolitics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label geopolitics. Show all posts

24 July 2010

Big Brother is watching

An amazing photo of a DPR Korean soldier peering through to see US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, while on a visit last week to Panmunjom on the DMZ dividing Korea. Clinton annouced even tougher sanctions on DPR Korea as punishment for the supposed Cheonan attack, an incident the UN even said in its ratified statement that Pyongyang was not responsible for. While at the DMZ, Clinton looked through binoculars into the North giving a sense that entry into the reclusive country was forbidding, despite the fact that her husband had been there last year. The hope now, like that with other unsuccessful blockades elsewhere (Cuba in particular) is that by strangling the country economically will lead to further hardship and an eventual popular uprising to usher in capitalism. However, in practice such sanctions only give the authorities further opportunity to easily blame all economic failings on the hated American imperialists and their blockade. The only people who suffer are the poor and powerless, the people the USA ostensibly want to help.

18 July 2010

Soap opera diplomacy: How Turkey is winning the Balkans and losing Israel

Much has been reported lately of Turkey's renewed confidence as a regional power and its moves for even greater worldwide influence. Firm evidence of this is the Iran nuclear deal it brokered along with an equally ambitious Brazil. What hasn't been picked up as much is that Turkey is finally winning the hearts and minds of a group of peoples with deep-felt historic animosity towards it - the Christian peoples of the Balkan. Last week, the Turkish prime minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan an made important visit to the Balkans, visiting majority Orthodox Christian countries Serbia and Bulgaria along the way. Despite hysterical and at times ridiculous protests by ultra-nationalists in both countries, Erdoğan's meetings were extremely successful, resulting in many and much needed infrastructure projects being discussed and approved.

Historically Turkey has been seen by the Christians of the Balkans as the cruel occupier, with Turks themselves painted as vicious and murderous, a view much more reflecting the Western stereotype of Muslims from previous centuries than actual first hand experience. It doesn't take long for Christian Balkanites to bring up how much they suffered under 5 centuries of Turkish rule, which is a throw away excuse given for any perceived backwardness they may have. Whole national identities, such as Greek, Serbian and Bulgarian ones, are based around this hatred of Turks and sense of revenge for the humiliation and degredation over such a long time.

Turkophobia naturally does not extend to the Muslim populations of the Balkans, many of whom are ethnic Turks themselves, who see Turkey as a protector of their interests and welfare, a role Turkey has always willing accepted. Turkey provided as much support as it could to the Bosniaks in the Balkan Wars, was one of the first countries to recognise Kosovo independence, maintains very strong relations with Macedonia and has always championed the rights of Muslims throughout the region. This is the basis for the argument Balkan Christian ultra-nationalists have that Muslim populations represent a fifth column showing more loyalty to Turkey than to their homelands.

So why are things different now? Serbs should be angry at Erdoğan for recognising their 'Jerusalem' (Kosovo) as a separate country, but they aren't. Television is the answer. Turkish soap operas, subtitled or dubbed depending on the country, have taken the Balkans by storm in the past 2 years. After almost 2 decades of constantly watching increasing monotonous plot lines of cheap Latin American soaps, the higher production values, more intricate storylines and, most importantly, the closeness of Turkish cultural dynamics with those of the Balkans, has seen ratings for Turkish soap opera, and consequently for Turkey, go up. The first soap to make a breakthrough was Binbir Gece (1001 Nights), making its stars massively famous beyond Turkey.


The success of Turkey's soap operas has come as a surprise to Turks. Turkey has been wanting for decades to regain a part of past glories when the Ottoman Empire was responsible for bringing technological and culinary advances to peoples around the world. With the fall of Communism, Turkey hinged its hopes at spreading its influence to Turkic speaking countries of ex-USSR and to Muslims in the Balkans. Results from this policy have been patchy, whereas Turkish culture and business ties have made some inroads, it still faces very hard competition (from Russia in particular) in most fields. Turkey's ineffectiveness in exerting any influence over recent conflicts between Turkic speaking Uzbeks and Kyrgyz showed the little extent Turkey's political reach has over Central Asia, for instance.

While Turkish soap operas have been instrumental in building closer ties with the Balkans, unfortunately the opposite can be said of once-close Turkish-Israeli relations. Part of the rather rapid deterioration of relations between the Western allies came at the hands of controversial Turkish soap opera Kurtlar Vadisi (The Valley of Wolves). Playing on deep-held Turkish public views of widespread political conspiracy, Kurtlar Vadisi has sporned a whole series of politically-based soaps and films that have been hugely popular in Turkey and Turks everwhere, and now abroad (the first series is currently being shown in Kosovo, Albania and Macedonia). Topics the series has covered include US military activity in Iraq, Kurdish terrorism, Turkish army control and the mafia, mainly in a populist/Islamist viewpoint much in line with the beliefs of the main Turkish viewing demographic. What made Israel's foreign ministry particularly angry (coming after Erdoğan's outburst at Davos in January 2009 - the startpoint to the current Turkish-Israeli rift) was one episode depicting Israeli Mossad agents stealing Turkish babies. The soap had come under earlier criticism of anti-semitism when it depicted a Jewish-American doctor harvesting body organs from captured Turkish soldiers in Iraq and selling them in Tel Aviv. Israel's foreign ministry, run by the far-right Avigdor Lieberman, later handled the situation very undiplomatically (and stupidly) by publicly humiliating the Turkish ambassador in Israel, resulting in a worsening of relations with its closest Muslim ally. As often is the case in such pathetic acts, the Israeli deputy foreign minister's farcical actions of oneupmanship did not lead to any improvement of the situation, nor did the Turkish authorities apply the extra censorship requested. On the other hand, by actually making an issue out of it only caused Kurtlar Vadisi to gain more viewership especially from secular Turks who otherwise were not watching the soap as they were well aware of its pro-Islamist/populist tone.

Nevertheless, the future looks bright for Turkey and its greater aspirations of cultural expansion, thanks to the glitz. With the EU in economic crisis, membership into the Christian European club seems unlikely, but Turkey's economy and confidence is growing without it. It remains to be seen whether Turkey can capitalise more from the soap opera success in opening the minds of the Balkans. But, if so many centuries of animosity can help cast off the image of the bad Turk in the Balkans, then what if Israel were to have a chance at watching a Turkish soap (other than Kurtlar Vadisi)? Perhaps these once friends now enemies could, like in the soaps, have a happy ending.

11 July 2010

An empty airbase in Tajikistan scene of new Central Asian superpower intrigue

Interesting article about the empty Ayni air base in the former Soviet republic of Tajikistan and the latest twists and implications of foreign powers jostling for influence in Central Asia. Located south west from the capital Dushanbe, Ayni had been renovated by the Indians in the mid-noughties but has remained disused since. As the article states, this was seen as a possible start for India's greater ambitions of military superpower status:

"Analysts of India's military suggest those expectations may have been too ambitious. When the base renovations started in 2004, India did not have a clear plan as to how it would eventually utilize the facility, said one source close to the Indian armed forces, whose employer does not allow him to speak on the record. "The point, sadly, remains the same: While the Tajik government has kept doors open, at least in a limited sense, the government here [in India] hasn't quite gotten its act together about precisely what or how to leverage the opportunity," he said.

Some analysts said India's foray into base politics was motivated by a desire to play the role of great power. "India is playing a game," said Imran Baig, a Washington-based analyst of South Asian security. "To maintain a base with no aircraft is not expensive at all," he said. "But to deploy a high-tech fighter squadron full time at a remote location far from the country of origin is a very, very costly affair and can only be afforded by superpowers."

Still, India appears to want to keep the question of its presence at Ayni open. India's president, Pratibha Patil, visited Dushanbe last year, an indicator to both Indian and Tajik experts that India was still trying to court Tajikistan."

Looks like that the GFR of late derailed India's first steps of expanding its military reach beyond the Indian Ocean and immediate vicinity.

The article goes on to suggest that Tajikistan's president Imomolai Rahmon, is applying the same tactics of playing off the various foreign powers with Ayni that the former Kyrgyzstani president Bakiev used with the Manas air base, in order to extract as much gain as possible. However, Rahmon is effectively propped up by Russia and is in no position to say no to his current and historical political patrons .

Considering Tajikistan's position right next to Afghanistan and the precarious future of Manas in Kyrgyzstan, speculation points to possible US use of the base. American officials deny having any interest in the base, despite its advantageous location, but more likely the Russians would not appreciate their client state consenting to US use of Ayni.

01 July 2010

When will we realise, like the Russians did in 1987, that Afghanistan is not 'winnable'?

Let's face it - the Taliban are winning in Afghanistan, as much as I loathe them. All talk of surges (i.e. offensives), foreign fighters (not the Arab mujahadeen but NATO forces) and capturing the hearts and minds is all in vain. The kneejerk reaction by the Bush administration to invade Afghanistan October 2001 in a display of primitive revenge for 9/11, and to secure vital transit routes to Central Asia's natural resources has resulted in the prolonged suffering of the Afghan people. War for them has been ongoing since the late 1970s and now even the grandchildren of the original fighters are fighters themselves. Afghanistan is now the longest war that US forces have been engaged in, even longer than Vietnam, yet there seems to be no end in sight. Of course, when foreign forces are up against local people fighting for their own country, and have many decades experience of fighting in their rough terrain, there is no doubt who will end up victor, no matter what sophisticated technology is used.

I was reading a report by BBC News World Affairs Editor, the highly respected John Simpson on an interview with Taliban forces. Usually I like his viewpoint on most matters, however here he has taken a rather patronising take on the Taliban's position. Simpson talks down the Taliban's view that they are winning, NATO forces are in disarray and refusal to talk to them, passing it off as propaganda. The point is however, that NATO is even suggesting talks with the Taliban must mean that things are not going well.
The cruel irony of the current conflict in Afghanistan is that it was created and maintained in the 1970s and 1980s by those very same NATO forces. Following a communist revolution in the late 1970s, Afghanistan embarked on a wide-ranging modernisation campaign. When Islamist forces, buoyed by the success of the 1979 Islamic revolution in Iran, threatened to stop these processes and also spread Islamism into bordering poor Muslim Soviet republics like Uzbekistan and Tajikistan, the Soviet Union stepped in ostensibly to protect the communist revolution, but more so to contain the threat of Islamic instability in the USSR itself. This is much like the same reason why NATO forces under US leadership invaded Afghanistan in 2001. Most of the world outside of the Soviet bloc condemned the Soviet invasion, most visibly with a now-hypocritical 64 country boycott of the 1980 Summer Olympics in Moscow, an event that were to be boycotted by the US and it Cold War allies anyway. After initial success, thanks mainly to the smart use of soldiers from Central Asian republics, the Soviets were facing defeat as the Afghan Islamist forces (the mujahadeen) became the recipients of American largesse and CIA training, solely for the US to fight their Cold War Soviet adversaries by proxy and without any foresight or in-depth knowledge by the US into the long-term goals of their clients. Most instrumental in the Mujahadeen struggle was the CIA equipping them with Stinger missles, turning the tide on Soviet armed superiority, and video cameras to win the PR war with damning footage. The Soviets, in their right mind, pulled out starting from 1987, leaving the communist Afghan government to fend for itself, which it did for another 5 years (even past the collapse of the USSR). The Mujahadeen eventually did win, though the new government quickly aligned itself with the anti-American Iranian government - so much US money went to finance a force which then went against them. The Soviet fear of the spread of Islamism was becoming true, but despite the collapse of the USSR, the old Communist Party apparatus in ex-Soviet republics such as Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan remained on the basis of containing this threat, while Tajikistan itself became the scene of a ferocious civil war in 1993 involving Islamist forces on one side. The supposed US interest for spreading the principles of a free and open society and democracy had no chance, but then again, those principles are usually just a smokescreen for personal national interests, as has been the case recently in Kyrgyzstan, or much like the USSR's involvement in Afghanistan.

The US was not happy with the new pro-Iran Afghan government, so it was business as usual when the US exploited clan-based warlords who ostensibly opposed the government in Kabul but who shared the US interest in contuining warfare as it was proitable for them. One of these groups based in the southern city of Kandahar were the extremely-religious Taliban (the Students), who made sweeping victories across Afghanistan and eventually toppled the government in 1996. Much has been documented of the Taliban's rather literal and extreme interpretation of the Qur'an, much in line with the backward and primitive nature of society of its mainly rural base. By 9/11, the Taliban were accused of harbouring Islamic terrorists who threatened the US, much the same way that the Soviets accused the Mujahadeen of harbouring terrorists who threatened the Soviet Union's southern flank just over the mountainous river border.

So what do we have now? Well, the USA made a big mess of it here, solely out of the shortsightedness of its Cold War policies rather than actively pursuing humanistic principles that it superficially espouses. The US has paid big time for its actions, being the victim of the world's most devastating terrorist attack and having it occur on its own territory, masterminded by a terrorist the US itself had trained. The US has poured billions of wasteful dollars into a war that has dragged on while using the same failed tactic of sophisticated technology will win the day that led the Soviets to lose 20+ years earlier. Financing and training the mujahadeen has proven to be counterproductive in the long run as the US also destroyed the only Afghan government to actually launch the types of social reforms such as gender equality, Western universal education, literacy and modernisation which, with a little foresight, could have laid the seeds for eventual democratisation in Afghanistan and not for compromises to US security. The US have condemned the Afghan people to decades of war and despair, while neighbouring countries such as Uzbekistan live in totalitarianism thanks mainly to the threat of instability and the spread of Islamism from its neighbour's perpetual war. The best thing for the US and NATO forces to do is that they do what the Soviets did back in 1987 - get out. Leave the Afghans alone as they have suffered enough. As long as NATO forces remain in Afghanistan, there will be a war.