Showing posts with label National Identity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label National Identity. Show all posts

15 September 2010

10 years on from Freeman's victory - 2000 Sydney Olympics

Wow, to think that 10 years ago, Sydney was hosting the Olympics and the whole of Australia was in sports and nationalistic delirium. Nick Bryant of the BBC has yet again given a perfect retrospective of the Games and its legacy, highlighting the possible scenarios that London and the UK could face leading up to, and following, the 2012 Olympics.

One of the most important points made by Bryant is that the Olympics signified the startpoint of Australia's ongoing jingoistic nationalism, something I have been trying to pinpoint for quite some time. Forever since blinded by the spell the success and praise the Olympics had on the nation, when Australia was overcome with immense civic pride and 'flying the flag' became second nature, Aussies have become what was previously uncharacteristically nationalistic. National symbols such as the flag and the boxing kangaroo, which were hardly to seen outside of major sporting events like the cricket, became mainstream and even fashionable. As Bryant quotes:

Struck by the new-found prominence of flags and face-paint nationalism, the journalist Jennifer Hewett pithily observed that Australia's traditional "mute stoicism" had been replaced by an "open patriotic eagerness". According to James Curran and Stuart Ward, the authors of an excellent new history, The Unknown Nation: Australia After Empire, Sydney suggested that Australians "had shelved their traditional suspicion of overt nationalistic behaviour by revelling in frantic flag-waving".

This eagerness was quickly promoted and harnessed by the ruling Liberal Party under the leadership John Howard which assisted them to two further electoral victories in 2001 and 2004. The long-term effect has been that all aspects of Australian society have had to adopt and incorporate this crass form of national pride into their discourse, despite its polarising, isolationalist and underlying racist nature that it seems to encourage.

The most significant moment at the Sydney Olympics for most Australians was when Catherine Freeman was the first Aborigine to win an individual Olympic gold medal for Australia, in the womens 200 metre sprint. The moment itself is subject to much controversy and was hijacked and exploited. Nevertheless, this deep down was a great personal victory for Freeman herself.

Let's get through the muck first. First of all, Freeman, whose fascinating family history was covered in an episode of the first Australian series of Who Do You Think You Are, had her identity taken over from day one in that she is rarely referred to by her real name - Catherine, the name all of her friends and family call her. Instead, to Australia she is 'Cathy Freeman', a name she detests, but nevertheless rather symbolic of how she was subject to the whims of others. Despite much success worlwide in her talents as a sprinter, most of white Australia only found out about her when in 1994 Commonwealth Games, after winning the women's 200m, controversy raged when she celebrated her win by waving the Aboriginal flag and not the Australian flag. The then rather opinionated Head of the Australian Commonwealth Games team criticsed Freeman for waving the Aboriginal flag. Freeman drew much scorn from the Australian public and media for this, giving an excuse for many to let out their latent racism towards Aborigines. However, after she consequently won the 400ms, she waved both the Australian and Aboriginal flags as a compromise.
The Australian media later were to make much of a 'great rivalry' between Freeman and her main opponent, France's Marie-José Pérec. The French woman won the 200ms at Atlanta in 1996, but with the Olympics on Freeman's home soil in 2000, the Australian public were wanting no less than gold from 'their girl'. Such was the pressure that the Australian media went into overtime in rubbishing Pérec when she was in Sydney. The extent of Australian media harrassment and the accompanying media-generated hostility towards Pérec in the lead up to the race against Freeman was so intense that she was forced to quit the Olympics prior to the race and return to France. This was seen as a great 'victory' against the 'evil' Pérec in the eyes of many Australians. What was not widely reported that Freeman was horrified by this as, despite media reports, she was good friends with Pérec and they actually enjoyed a friendly rivalry. Freeman later ran and won the 200m, much to the joy of the Australian public.

The Australian public and media saw Freeman's lighting of the Olympic flame at the Opening Ceremony and her subsequent victory in the 200ms as a great achievement and a symbol of reconciliation. But that was just it - symbolic. By using 'Cathy' as the face of the most watched event in the world, gave the false but powerful image that Australia's Aborigines are fully integrated and respected in Australia. In other words, how could Aussies be possibly racist then... we have 'Cathy' Freeman.

But there was always someone who never bought this imposed image - Catherine Freeman herself. Freeman's articulation, on first impressions, is how many Aussies would like their Aborigines to appear - simple, naive and vulnerable. However, they are all fooled. Freeman is actually very perseptive, displays great intuition and intellect, and is extremely capable of using what may seem her outward vulnerabilities to subtely and unsuspectingly attack public expectations of what is accepted as 'correct'. One of her unsung crowning moments where she displayed this tactic was when interviewed after winning the 200ms at Sydney. In what could be best described as yet another example of 'multicultural window dressing', a fact not lost on Freeman, she was interview by the only mainstream Aboriginal TV presenter in Australia, Ernie Dingo. He did exactly as was expected from such a set-up situation - focus on how much her winning means to Aboriginal Australia and to reconcilliation. Freeman was going to have nothing of it and didn't play along with this charade of whitewashing over 200 years of the systematic holocaust of Aborigines. When asked about what she was thinking about when running the race, which Dingo encouraging her to say something of significance to Aborigines, Freeman in her own innocent style totally avoided the 'Aboriginal Australia' aspect that was expected from her and instead spoke the truth:

(To paraphrase): 'Well, when I was running, I saw my brother on the side and I saw him smiling and he hasn't smiled in years so I was happy that he was smiling'.

Catherine, I love you for that answer! What Freeman said with that answer is she ran as a human being and not as a person to be used to say that all is well with Australia's treatment of Aborigines.

Despite Dingo's many stubborn, and ultimately embarrassing, attempts to get Freeman to say something as clichéd about Aboriginal reconciliation as his questions, it was to no avail.

Freeman has also given measured but well-timed digs at her then growing personality cult. Later in 2000, at the Australian Sports Personality of the Year, as expected, she won the big gong, but when begrudgingly accepting the award, she potently said that 'there shouldn't be awards like this'.

Freeman retired in 2003 and since then has kept a reasonably low profile (especially compared to many, less-accomplished, retired Australian athletes), though she has made appearances on such TV shows as 'We Can Be Heroes/The Nominees' (a great satirical dig at the 'Australian of the Year' award, of which Freeman is a past recipient) and on Salam Café, a fringe TV show on SBS featuring Australian Muslim comedians. Her appearance on the show produced what would be the best line in the whole series from one of the comedians; when asked about her trademark running bodysuit (pictured below), based on which one of the comedians described Freeman as the first gold medalist to win wearing hijab, she was asked 'did your husband make you wear that?' Freeman's final comments on the 'Who Do You Think You Are' episode also displays her great intellect and how she is, to use the jingoistic clichés that go hand-in-hand with the Olympics, more than just gold medal material.

If only we could have more athletes like Catherine Freeman who transcend the political, social and commercial manipulation that the Olympics have been subject to since its 're-inception' in 1896. As Bryant describes:

No other event, forum or theatre, whether military, diplomatic, commercial, cultural or sporting, has presented such an opportunity for the country to assert itself so unambiguously in terms of its own choosing.

In a sparsely populated and occasionally neglected country, with a sometimes fragile sense of self-esteem, few aspects of national life have delivered more uncomplicated joy than the sight every four years of a group of athletes heading abroad and returning with a haul of gold, silver and bronze - international sport's highest currency of success.

This applies to many nations. Instead of wars, we have had the Olympics to assert national pride. I personally prefer this to warfare, but I would like to see this happen in good measure and cleanly.

25 July 2010

The 5 biggest lies about changing Macedonia's name

From taratur.com ('taratur' is better known as 'tzatziki' in English speaking countries)

The spin doctors operating in some of Macedonia's political parties and media, who tirelessly work for the Greek cause use a few tricks all with the purpose to convince the Macedonian public to change its own name and to accept the compromise proposal 'Republic of North Macedonia'. This time we will show that their 'arguments' have as much worth as Yugoslav dinars.

Lie number 1
The name has already been changed and they're just waiting for a date for that to be announced


This is a line being put forward by Macedonian opposition parties and their media fellow travellers (columnists and 'experts'), all for the purpose of weaking the so-called 'hard core' who under no circumstances want to change the name; a reason why the current Macedonian government still polls very high. Their impetus can be witnessed in two segments - the first is clearly partisan, while the second is clearly in cooperation with Greek political elements that so far remain in the domain of speculation.

That is to say, partisan logic suggests that because the biggest reason for the high approval ratings for the current ruling nationalist party is their strong stance on the name issue, if they were to change the name, no doubt their high opinion polls would mindspinningly tumble, being that they will lose the largest part of the trust they had obtained. So here is the opposition's chance.

In other words, by witnessing the daily Macedonian political scene, you see politicians constantly describing their political opponents as false patriots misleading the public. If this were to be proven (i.e. if the ruling party changes the name), automatically the opposition will come to power claiming in part that it was right about the ruling party's treachery all the time, and that valuable time was just lost.

The second element can be found in the connections of prominent opposition party members, 'experts' etc. with Greek political elements, as evident even in the book written by independent Macedonia's first president Kiro Gligorov. It's not possible to go into detail now, however a large section of the Macedonian public believes that soon enough lists of Macedonian journalists, quasi-experts and the like who are on the Greek payroll will be released.

Why is this a lie?
1. Because if a Macedonian government at any time were to announce a name change, they would face losing government and would end up being on the backburner of history, just like their party predecessor who was held up as a 'legend' but finished up less than glorious. Furthermore, the chances of a popular uprising are very high, something that would have an uncertain end.
2. Because they have been saying this now for 4 years and may continue to do so for another 40, but the aim will be only to weaking the Macedonian resolve. In other words, this lie is as effective as a pogo stick in quicksand.
3. Because if this was true, then the current Macedonian government would not have launched legal proceedings against Greece at the International Court in The Hague, or make moves in an attempt to mimick Greek policy (statues of ancient heroes etc.), nor constantly insist that there would be a referendum on the name. If it were so, the government would simply wait for a lull before announcing capitulation.

Lie Number 2
Any other name is better than 'Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia' (FYROM)

And this hypothesis comes from the same circles and has the same purpose as lie number 1 - to weaken Macedonia's positions in talks and to brainwash the Macedonian public. In other words, according to this hypothesis, FYROM is a 'necrophilic' name that is much worse than 'North' therefore the name should be changed immediately by accepting the Greek proposal.

Why is this a lie?
1. Because it is wrongly devised. Namely, FYROM is a 'reference' and not the legal 'name' by which Macedonia is represented at UN and other international organisations. So long as there is this 'reference' Macedonia can fight to receive international support through the recognition of its true name - Republic of Macedonia, which it has been doing these past 18 years, and has achieved from over 120 countries worldwide. If Macedonia were to accept a change in name, then it's the end to all this. Macedonia would have to accept the name Republic of North Macedonia and bye-bye to the Macedonian name.
2. Because noone so far (except Greek nationalists) have used terms such as Fyromian for the language or people of Macedonia. Macedonians are still referred to as Macedonians by an overwhelming majority of the world's population or, at the very least, citizens of FYR Macedonia by the bean counters in Brussels. If the name 'Republic of North Macedonia' were to be accepted, as much as they convince otherwise, Macedonians will become 'North Macedonians' just like how the citizens of North Korea are known as 'North Koreans' and the citizens of South Africa as 'South Africans', as the term 'Macedonian' will imply citizens of Greece with Greek ethnicity that live in the Greek region of Macedonia. That's how it says in Wikipedia, in the UN and all other powerful organisations. That is Greece's aim - so much so that their leaders don't even hide this fact.
3. Because in the name talks, the Greeks are also placing additional conditions which not only mean a change of Macedonia's name but also a change of identity and prefixes and such. With the current 'reference', the Macedonians are not obligated to use the term 'Fyromians' or 'Fyromese' etc.
4. Because to the rest of the unencumbered world, Macedonians are still Macedonians. If you were to go to ... say Jamaica, there the gracious hosts will greet you as 'Macedonians'. However if Macedonia was to capitulate, expect to be awaited as 'North Macedonians', not matter how much you were to protest, as a name change would imply acceptance of being called that.
5. Because the Greeks would not smear their reputation as a 'problematic' country in foreign policy terms if they were happy with FYROM. Greece knows that if Macedonia were to enter the EU and NATO even under the FYROM reference, Macedonia soon enough would be freed from this cumbersome reference and win the dispute fully. The Greeks are fully aware that this reference is just plain silly to other countries, so that's why they are in full force in trying to pressure Macedonia to sign capitulation. To get this to happen, they have engaged the services of a large number of Macedonian journalists and quasi-experts who cry like little babies when someone, or they themselves are called 'traitors'.

Lie Number 3
The name must be changed (to solve the dispute) otherwise the Albanians will split

According to this construct, which also have the goal of scaring little children from their sleep, the Albanians are war-like people but also supposedly pro-European orientated, and who won't be waiting for the Macedonians to solve this 'irrational dispute' as the Albanians want express entry into the EU and NATO. That's why they'll go up in arms and will separate so as to join NATO and EU.

Why is this a lie?
1. Because this relies on many conditions and many shaky foundations. First of all, it is not for certain that without hesitation the EU would accept a supposedly war-like people facing huge problems with mafia and terrorist formations in all territories where they live (the Albanian mafia is seen to be one of the most problematic in the world), where weddings are characterised by the shooting of guns and armaments, and drug and prostitution trafficking has deeply entered into many facets of Albanian society. That's not to talk about the current anti-Muslim mood in a majority of European countries that are ever increasingly banning burqas, niqabs, minarets etc.
2. If the Albanians were to want to separate, it can be safe to assume that Macedonia will not allow that to happen in a peaceful way, which means that it would result in a military conflict, something noone wants - neither the citizens of Macedonia, nor neighbouring countries, let alone the EU and the USA. This means that if there were to be a new military conflict, the whole Balkans will remain, as now, stagnant for many more years. Therefore the Albanians would not get express entry into the EU or NATO. On the contrary, it would mean that Albania would remain outside the gates of Europe for many, many more years! This scenario was even warned by a group of Albanian intellectuals on TV in Albania's capital Tirana last year when they confronted the Albanian nationalist leader from Macedonia Menduh Thaqi, that his irredentist policies were working against the interests of all Albanians.
3. Let me pose to you a rhetorical question. If integration into the EU was more important for the Albanians than their national issues, then why did Kosovo then separate from Serbia? According to all indications, Serbia will integrate and join the EU much quicker than an independent Kosovo. Why then didn't they just simply remain as part of Serbia so they can enter the EU quicker, rather than form their own country, which for at least 10 years has no chance to even think about starting talks on EU membership? However, the fact is that when their national issues are at stake, they come first. Macedonia should be the same. Macedonia must keep its name and identity the same way how Macedonia understood Albanians' interest for Kosovo being independent, hence recognising it as an independent country.

Lie Number 4
Only in the EU and NATO can Macedonia survive


According to this construct, Macedonia cannot develop economically and politically by itself. On the contrary, Macedonia's survival is uncertain and that it's only a matter of time that the country will collapse, disappear or experience a cataclysm.

This lie has been told for more than 10 years and to be honest, its propensity gains strength only when the Macedonia's nationalist party is in power. This can be seen by going through Macedonian media archives and files on internet from the period when the ex-Communists were in power from 2002-2006, when none of the doomsdayers were emphasising this lie.

Why is this construct a lie?
1. Firstly, the creators of this lie never elaborate on their fatal scenario. Basically, what will happen with Macedonia and how will it 'no longer exist'. Will Macedonia be occupied by a neighbouring country; will it be bombed by a nuclear bomb; or will Macedonia be overcome by a serious plague? They just simply say that there won't be any more Macedonians, but how this will happen is not that clear. Honestly, I'm not planning of getting rid of myself anytime soon, nor do I think that at least another 2 million people, the population of Macedonia, are planning the same. That would mean someone would need to exterminate all 2 million of Macedonia's population. How this will happen? Please, could someone who says such constructs please explain?
2. Secondly, because in the course of history, this has proven to be a lie. It only serves to scare little children, while Macedonia still survives. It is not that Macedonians are satisifed being outside of the EU and NATIO and have little or no economic growth, but simply that the price to be paid for this, to self-renounce ourselves as a nation and people, is unacceptable.
3. Because the world's current power circles just would not allow Macedonia to collapse. The world's greater powers are fine with Macedonia and they are involved in the country with their economic and political structures, so they have no interest in making the fate of Macedonia's future uncertain.

Lie Number 5
By solving the name issue (by changing and selling the name Macedonia), it will all be milk and honey


This lie is the 'carrot', as opposed to the 'sticks' of the previous ones. Accordingly, when Macedonia changes its name, the hard transition period since the early 1990s will come to an immediate end, Macedonia will finally join the EU and NATO and all of its current economic, social and political problems will be solved. The Macedonians then will live happily ever after in Eldorado to the end of their lives. We just don't know who is the prince and who is the princess...

Why is this a lie?
1. Because every other 'carrot' so far have ended up as a lie. Macedonia changed its flag under pressure in 1995, accepted the reference FYROM under pressure, accepted more than 300,000 refugees fleeing Kosovo under pressure (despite Macedonia having no resources to look after such numbers), accepted a new Framework Agreement after a limited ethnic conflict in 2002 under pressure, and for all of the 'carrots' dangled in front of it for all this, it has come to nothing. Macedonia just desecrates itself, while Eldorado is looking much further away than the planet of Pluto.
2. Because if it were to change the name, Macedonia won't gain express entry to the EU. Instead talks will start which will drag out for 5-6 years minimum. That means that for Eldorado to arrive, Macedonians will need to wait at least that many years PLUS even more years on top for any possible economic effects (if any) from ever dwindling EU funds to achieve their minimum effect. That's notwithstanding all possible unpleasant future economic scenarios that are ever more present in recent times.
3. Because joining the EU and NATO has not solved Bulgaria's serious problems with corruption and poverty, while Greece is financially and socially bankrupt and will be in a terrible economic crisis for many years to come. Belgium is still threatened with a political split into Flanders and Walloonia entities, even though Brussels is the effective capital of the EU. If the above construct was true, then none of these countries would be facing these problems they have at present. Simply, the EU and NATO membership does not automatically mean all problems will be solved. Entry into these structures only means better political and economic conditions on certain terms and a possibility for greater prosperity, however not at the price of renouncing national identity.

In conclusion, the price to be paid in changing the name is just too much for what most likely will be too little. The rebuttal to Lie 5 say it best. The idea that EU membership will solve everything and that Macedonia overnight will become as prosperous and efficient as Germany is a delusion. Greece today, despite 30 years of billions of euros and the superficial application of EU standards, is still a corrupt, inefficient and essentially poor country no much different from Macedonia now (only with better roads). Some Macedonians consider the EU to be, either positively or negatively, as the new Tito Yugoslavia, when Macedonians lived like the Greeks of late - an artificially high standard of living funded by subsidies from northerly Germanic regions and credit, without any fundamental change to age-old traditions of corruption, nepotism and political patronage. Macedonia is still paying for that period, but a name change to only get the same will be even more devastating on identity and esteem. Fortunately most Macedonians are quite aware of this, that's why applying their first-hand experience with that other union of European nations - Yugoslavia, they see that multi-ethnic unions don't last. As what one Macedonian friend once told me: The EU is, like Yugoslavia was, just temporary; the name and national identity is forever, so why pay that price forever for something temporary.

15 July 2010

Disappearing Austronesians?


Just came accross this claim in an article about efforts in Taiwan to save the endangered indigenous Austronesian languages of Taiwan:

'But of the world's estimated 300 million Austronesians - including New Zealand's Maoris and Hawaii's Polynesians - few can speak their language, and many languages now face extinction'.

Quite a claim to make considering that Malay, Filipino, Bahasa Indonesia, Malagasy and most indigenous languages spoken in Indonesia, Malaysia and the Phillippines are Austronesian; all of which are thriving and growing in numbers of speakers. Indonesia is, after all, the fourth most populous country in the world, so this claims rings hollow.

Essentially there are two small but crucial errors to this claim. First is designating speakers of Austronesian languages as the one ethnicity. Yes, the peoples of Madagascar, Indonesia and the Maoris may speak languages of the same language family, but they don't necessarily share the same ethnicity. Likewise, it would be to say that all English, Russian, Hindi and Spanish speakers are all 'Indo-Aryans' as those languages are from the same language family too. If we were to go by this idea that language group equals ethnicity, then all native English speakers would also be classed as 'Germans', as it is a 'Germanic' language.

The second mistake is the line 'few speak their language'. This could be interpreted in the wrong way. What would be more accurate to say is that out of all Austronesian speakers, the overall number who speak their native Austronesian language is slowly decreasing. Definitely not the case in Malaysia, Madagascar or many Pacific Islands but very much so in multi-ethnic and populous Phillippines and Indonesia, where indigenous Austronesian languages are slowly being supplanted by the official Austronesian national languages of Filipino and Bahasa Indonesia respectively.

In attempting to report, caution should be taken when making such bold and ultimately erroneous claims.

12 July 2010

Srebrenica and Bratunac - how the Bosnian war is still seen differently by each of the sides involved

15 years ago 7000 Bosniak men of 'military age', meaning 15 years upwards, were killed by Bosnian Serb forces over a period of 5 days, marking the worst massacre in European history since World War 2. Commemoration of the event is usually marked with the burial of newly identified bodies. Most significantly is that this year the president of Serbia, Boris Tadić paid tribute to the victims by his presence at the ceremony held yesterday, inciting mixed feelings from Bosniaks and Serbs. Nevertheless, the Serbian government's acknowledgement of the atrocity is important for the region and avoiding a repeat of such madness ever happening again.

Unfortunately, Tadić and his brave actions are being overshadowed with Serbs who are focusing on other events. While Bosniaks and the World draw attention on the 11th July to events that happened in Sreberenica in 1995, many Serbs place greater focus on a massacre of 70 Serbs by Bosniaks in villages around the town of Bratunac, on the 12th July 1992. In commemoration ceremonies mirroring those held down the road in Srebrenica the day before, local Serb leaders strived to point out what they see as 'selective justice'. Bosnian Serb president Milorad Dodik said in a speech that he doesn't dispute that Bosniaks perished in Srebrenica, but his main point is that if the Srebrenica massacre is considered 'genocide', then equal footing should be given to what happened to Serbs in the area in 1992. Meanwhile, Serbian media on the whole has given scant reporting about the 15th anniversary of Srebrenica, instead highlighting how over 3000 Serbs were killed in the whole region of Bosnia bordering Serbia during the war.

What is important and, ultimately, worrying is what is not reported and how the 'facts' are presented. Essentially, in the Serb view of events, we have the persistent elements of victimhood, one of the core natures of the Serbian national psyche, and injustice perpetuated. Many Serbs saw, and still see, themselves as hopeless and sole victims of the Balkan Wars, like they perceive to have been in all past Balkan conflicts. They believe the World is against them and that noone understands or cares for their precarious plight. The sense that justice is selective is consistent in their belief that there is a International War Crimes Tribunal bias against Serbs (far more Serbs have been convicted for war crimes than any other Balkan nationality). However, this thinking is as delusional as their view on events.

What is hypocritical is how the Serbs accuse the World of 'selective justice' when they themselves are as selective on their view of the past. The fact constantly rammed by the Serbian media is that 3000 Serbs died during the war in the region around Srebrenica. What they conveniently leave out is that this number of deaths was spread out over a 4.5 year period. Now compare that to 7000 Bosniaks killed by Serbs in Srebrenica over 5 days in July 1995! Dodik, in his speech yesterday, alluded that the only reason why Srebrenica happened, whose number of deaths he believes is greatly exaggerated, was only in response to the earlier genocidal actions of the Bosniaks in 1992 against Serbs. So, harking to a primitive eye-for-an-eye ideal, what happened in Srebrenica was just 'self-defence'. But here the Serbs yet again display a hypocritical stance. As I reported the other day involving a drunk Serb climbing a minaret in the nearby Bosnian city of Zvornik, the Serbs, led by paramilitary thugs like the infamous Arkan, successfully 'ethnically cleansed' some cities of eastern Bosnia of Bosniaks in April-May 1992, 2 months before the massacre of Serbs in the area by Bosniak paramilitaries led by Naser Orić. Many innocent civilians of all nationalities were killed in these actions, such as the 31 Bosniaks in Bratunac killed on the 12th May 1992, but mentioning this is not good for the psyche and tarnishes what would be otherwise the victimhood status that many Serbs continue to believe and have as justification for consequent actions that, in all purposes, are best described as war crimes.

What is worrying about this is that it was this type of historical cherry-picking and black-and-white victimhood which led the Balkans into war in the first place in the early 1990s. That 15 years after such senseless destruction that the fundamentals which caused it have yet to be learnt does not provide a good perspective for the future. As is often the case in the Balkans, as time goes past, the finer details of such artrocities are blurred and embellished, an element of myth is added along with a growing sense of rage and revenge that ultimately is encouraged and exploited by unscrupulous types fuelled foremost by self-interest.

What needs to be done is that everyone must recognise that everyone suffered - parents lost children, children - parents, lives destroyed, regardless of nationality. As the first foreign minister of Macedonia said to Belgian TV in 1993, what the Balkans produces excessively is history and every Balkan nation claims that history has not been too kind to them. What I say is that all the Balkans, not just the Serbs, needs to get over the whole victim complex, admit that everyone was guilty in some way, build a new bridge over the River Drina and move on. To repeat the same mistakes as before will only lead to a path of what should far too familiar destruction.
To give a better insight into the madness of the Bosnian War, a great book to read is 'They Wouldn't Hurt A Fly' by Croatian writer Slavenka Drakulić. The chapter about the Srebrenica massacre from the eyewitness report by one of the reluctant Serb soldiers ordered to kill then is frightening but human.

11 July 2010

Just split!

More than a million Catalans marched in Barcelona after a Spanish court ruled that there is no legal basis for classing Catalonia as a nation.
Such developments are observed in earnest in places like ex-Yugoslavia as its quite interesting to see the different approaches taken by powerful countries and associations like the USA and EU in dealing with these issues. When a multinational, socialist country like Yugoslavia faced similar problems about individual national identity, despite some superficial show of support for maintaining unity, the West more than facilitated Yugoslavia's quick dissolution into statelets which they later could control. The latest example of this madness was when the EU, idealistically championing for the dissolution of borders and bringing Europe closer together, supported Montenegro's rapid bid for independence in 2006, leading to yet more separation and another needless border drawn in the Balkans. However, when the same problems occur in allied capitalist countries like Spain, no support is given for nations like Catalonia to declare independence, draw new borders and dissolve national unions. Again, ex-Yugoslavs see this as double standards. I didn't like how Yugoslavia had mutated into a greater Serbia by the 1980s threatening individual nations of their identities, so likewise I fully support for Spain to dissolve completely and grant independence to the separate nations of Catalonia, Euskadi and Galicia. In any case, the differences between these nations and Castillian Spain are far greater than between the ex-Yugoslav statelets. Plus, there are more Catalan speakers than there are Danish, Norwegian, Latvian, Lithuanian, Croatian, Slovenian, Estonian or Slovakian speakers. Basically, if the EU sees fit that a country of 600,000 people like Montenegro should be an independent state, then so should Catalonia, a nation of 6 million!

29 June 2010

You're behaving like Miloš Bojanić!


As I reported a few days ago about Serbian turbofolk star and now reality show winner, Miloš Bojanić, the latest of the pathological lies typical of the backwardness of his Balkan rural mentality is that he defeated Ceca at the Poselo 202 song festival in 1995. In reality, Ceca defeated Bojanić by 4 votes, but details have never been a strong point with him, even if the Serbian press has splashed the truth across its pages.

Poselo 202 was the name of a folk music programme on Radio Belgrade in the 1980s and 1990s instrumental in promoting turbofolk and, eventually, Serbian nationalism. Every year in January Poselo 202 would organise a grand concert to pick its singer of the year. 15,000 Serbs would pour in to sing the hits of their favourite turbofolk stars and be intoxicated in the frenzy of locally-made celebrity, music and national pride. A scary example of this madness is when in 1992, while heavy fighting engulfed Vukovar, Rade Vučković, Zoran Kalezić and Čobi whipped the Serbian audience into nationalist delirium with their song 'U boj, u boj, u boj!' (To Battle, To Battle, To Battle)

In the interview at the end of the clip, though he gives praise to Arkan's men in fighting the Croatians, there seems to be a sense of sadness and regret in Vučković's voice, somewhat suggesting that he wrote the song more as a way to keep with the madness of the time than anything else. As has always been the case in Eastern Europe, a music career has always depended on political patronage.

Once the Balkan wars of the early 90s finished, so did Poselo's purpose and slowly withered away.

Picking up the pieces of a shattered national identity


Interesting article analysing the English hysteric obsession on the fortunes of the national football team and why defeat at the World Cup is taken so badly.